简体中文界面。帖子、指南及政策正文保留原文;未对原文作自动翻译。

Cannot release the nest drawing with five unexplained contacts

BrunoChen1148 · 2025年6月23日 03:34 UTC

已关闭
BR
BrunoChen1148
I have a proposed FR5 inspection nest with five bottom contacts under a milled bracket. A sample sits on three, another sits on a different three, and the designer's answer is a stronger clamp. I am holding the drawing. I'd like the contact scheme explained before we spend money making the part obey it.

9 条回复

SA
SarahBaker0502

Ask which contacts establish the datum. Five equal-looking pads don't answer that.

20
BR
BrunoChen1148

Designer calls all five supports. The part drawing uses one base face as the datum. They haven't said how those five pads are meant to cope with variation in that face.

6
SA
SarahBaker0502

That's the missing answer. Have them show the intended location before discussing clamp force.

23
DA
DavidBennett0780

I would also check that the samples are identified and clean. Not because your objection is wrong, but because a burr on one sample can send a fixture review down a very long side road. Cheap thing to rule out.

5
SA
SarahBaker0502

Clean samples still won't explain five pads. I'd pursue both questions.

14
DA
DavidBennett0780

Both is what I meant. I have watched a team redesign around dirt under one part, so I tend to mention it early. I wouldn't let the designer use cleaning as the whole answer either.

7
PA
PavelCarter0962

Bruno, is the inspection intended to report the bracket in its free condition or under a specified restraint? That needs to be clear before anyone decides how much clamping is acceptable in this particular nest.

22
SA
SarahBaker0502

Yes. A firm clamp can make a lovely measurement of the shape you've forced into it.

12
RA
RaviArcher0389

I would put the sample numbers on the photos as well, because after our tray comparison I no longer trust a folder of near-identical metal bits to explain itself.

8

讨论已关闭

此讨论已连续六个月没有活动,现已关闭新回复。 最后活动: .