Why are we blaming loading when nobody measured the spacer blanks?

RobinBrooks0860 · 2026年2月21日 16:42 UTC

已关闭

主帖中文翻译暂不可用,以下显示英文原文;回复保留原文。 查看英文原文

RO
RobinBrooks0860
Our FR5 planning sheet lists how far each hand-loaded blank sticks out but not how long the blank is, and somehow the conclusion says inconsistent seating, which seems a remarkable amount of certainty from half a measurement.

15 条回复

TH
TheoArcher0410

Pair overall blank length with exposed length for each identified sample. Also agree the chuck reference with the setter. Otherwise two people can make equally careful measurements of different things.

6分
AN
AnikaBell0682

And check the end that meets the stop, not just the end you can see.

13分
AD
AdaBrown0912

Our burr was on that hidden end. Worth checking, not assuming it's yours.

14分
AI
AishaBennett0779

Have the setter define the intended seating and manual comparison method before taking another set of readings, while automatic loading remains outside this check.

-3分
RO
RobinBrooks0860

Setter and inspection agreed the reference and marked each blank, and the first paired measurements explain most of the spread through actual stock length, which the spreadsheet had politely ignored

12分
JO
JonasAli0198

What does most leave over, Robin? One awkward blank or variation across the lot?

13分
EM
EmmaCarter0985

Were any individual blanks repeated, so you can distinguish differences between blanks from differences in seating the same one?

12分
DA
DavidBarnes0606

Repeat the identified awkward one and ordinary blanks through that agreed check, rather than taking another handful and losing the links again

11分
RO
RobinBrooks0860

One blank gives a larger exposed reading on some repeats while ordinary ones are consistent, and the setter says that one feels different at the stop, so it is retained separately with its readings

4分
AN
AnikaBell0682

Did inspection find a damaged end on that one?

6分
RO
RobinBrooks0860

A raised edge on the stop end, yes, but we have not assumed it caused every longer reading just because it looks guilty

9分
AD
AdaBrown0912

Sensible. Mine was a burr; yours still needs the contact checked.

17分
AI
AishaBennett0779

Keep the blank's original condition documented and let the setter and inspection assess how that edge meets the intended stop, rather than changing the loading allowance around it.

7分
RO
RobinBrooks0860

They confirmed the raised edge makes that blank catch before full seating; ordinary conforming blanks remained repeatable, so the estimate now separates normal length variation from this rejected blank's seating fault

13分
TH
TheoArcher0410

Useful result. Has the corrected allowance reached the FR5 proposal itself, or is the old figure still living in the supplier's copy?

6分

讨论已关闭

此讨论已连续六个月没有活动,现已关闭新回复。 最后活动: .