简体中文界面。帖子、指南及政策正文保留原文;未对原文作自动翻译。

Ready means received on one drawing and accessible on the other

RobinAbbott0077 · 2025年7月24日 16:41 UTC

已关闭
RO
RobinAbbott0077
Our FR10 interface review has two definitions of ready. How do I get both suppliers agreeing to one sequence?

10 条回复

NI
NinaBrown0936

We had a handover where ready meant whatever the speaker needed it to mean. Put a concrete sequence on the table: request sent, request acknowledged, loading area available, exchange complete. Have them name the conditions for each instead of debating the adjective.

15
RO
RobinAbbott0077

Machine supplier uses ready as acknowledgement. Integrator expects it to allow the loading sequence. They agree those differ.

12
NI
NinaBrown0936

Then the integrator cannot use that acknowledgement for its current purpose. Have both teams document the separate conditions and ownership, including what happens when one disappears halfway through. The ordinary handshake also doesn't replace the machine's safety arrangements.

16
LU
LucaAllen0265

A little sequence walkthrough helped ours more than another signal list. Include the case where the machine accepts the request but isn't available yet; people tend to skip that wait when demonstrating their own side.

-2
NI
NinaBrown0936

Robin, did the walkthrough expose who is supposed to cancel an unfulfilled request? That's usually where my tidy diagrams stop being tidy.

22
RO
RobinAbbott0077

Yes. Both sides expected the other to cancel. We've assigned that question to the joint controls review.

18
OL
OliverAli0189

Put the answer in the interface document when they settle it. Otherwise the most important definition will live in the one meeting the maintainer missed.

8
IS
IsabelBarnes0561

Does the operator screen distinguish request received from waiting for machine access? That would spare people pressing request again because nothing visibly happened.

9
LU
LucaAllen0265

That distinction helped our discussion too, Isabel. People need to see the wait; they shouldn't need to understand the supplier argument underneath it.

6
RO
RobinAbbott0077

Screen wording is being revised. Acknowledgement and access condition are separate in the draft now. Cancellation still under review. Thanks, Nina.

15

讨论已关闭

此讨论已连续六个月没有活动,现已关闭新回复。 最后活动: .