Enough reach, incomplete drawing (Fairino FR5, machining fixture exchange)

FelixBarnes0545 · 2026年6月7日 15:31 UTC

回复讨论

主帖中文翻译暂不可用,以下显示英文原文;回复保留原文。 查看英文原文

FE
FelixBarnes0545
Our proposed use for Fairino FR5 is machining fixture exchange with a short steel blank in an enclosed machining cell, with 40 planned. The reach sketch suggests the fixture is accessible, but it includes neither the gripper body nor the open machine door. I need a fuller access check to inform our choice of arm.

21 条回复

MI
MiaAllen0296

Can you compare measured door geometry with the proposed gripper envelope? An offline layout including both may expose access issues that the reach sketch doesn't represent.

17分
FE
FelixBarnes0545

After comparing the outlines, I found that the proposed approach overlaps the door handle even though the workpiece itself clears. That explains the misleadingly comfortable result in my initial sketch.

5分
MI
MiaAllen0296

Use that measured layout to review the complete approach and retreat offline. Include the tool, cables and service access, then ask the integrator to assess a revised mounting arrangement.

17分
FE
FelixBarnes0545

The buyer has suggested choosing a larger arm. I'm unsure whether that would address the access issue or simply increase our purchase while leaving the obstruction unresolved.

13分
MI
MiaAllen0296

A larger arm should give you more mounting freedom, so that could be the easiest route to investigate.

7分
MI
MinaBennett0772

A different arm geometry may introduce its own clearance problems. Increasing reach doesn't establish that the proposed tool can pass the existing handle obstruction.

-3分
MI
MiaAllen0296

You're right; more mounting freedom isn't guaranteed. Check each candidate in the measured layout and only favour a larger arm if its full approach works better.

13分
JA
JaneChan1119

@MiaAllen0296 We had a different machine application where a good transfer layout put the pedestal across a service panel. Maintenance spotted the catch immediately.

13分
FE
FelixBarnes0545

@JaneChan1119 Checked ours. The suggested pedestal overlaps a panel opening too. More red pen for the drawing.

8分
NA
NadiaAllen0291

Would making the pedestal removable address service access, or would restoring its position introduce a further setup requirement to evaluate?

21分
MI
MiaAllen0296

Restoring location and checking the installation would become part of that proposal. Ask the integrator to compare it with a layout that preserves routine service access.

7分
FE
FelixBarnes0545

The fixture requires a straight approach segment. Should we establish that constraint in the model before exploring alternative positions for the robot base?

21分
MI
MiaAllen0296

Yes. Include the required entry direction and withdrawal conditions, not just an end pose. A reachable point can still have no usable approach with the proposed tool.

-2分
JA
JaneChan1119

For our machine, withdrawal with a held workpiece needed a different route from entry. The empty-tool model made the clearance look much better than it was.

12分
FE
FelixBarnes0545

I'll add both loaded and empty tooling to the model. The other unclear part of our quote is responsibility for the machine signals.

22分
MI
MinaBennett0772

Get the interface responsibility explicit. A robot supplier and machine contact can each assume the other has handled access permission and fixture state.

2分
NA
NadiaAllen0291

@MinaBennett0772 I'm having trouble distinguishing process readiness from safe entry because the sales description makes them sound equivalent. Does the machine-ready signal establish both?

21分
MI
MiaAllen0296

A process-ready signal isn't automatically a safety function. The qualified cell assessor needs to define protective measures and restart requirements separately from the production sequence.

1分
FE
FelixBarnes0545

Would a supervised trial with a representative fixture let us make useful progress on geometry while the machine interface responsibilities are still being defined?

18分
MI
MiaAllen0296

@FelixBarnes0545 It can, with an appropriate supervised procedure. Record the actual tool and mount, and make clear that the trial addresses geometry while interface work remains open.

1分

参与讨论

欢迎来到 Application Robot

所有人都可以阅读论坛。登录或注册后即可发起讨论、回复或上传照片。

忘记密码?

注册账号即表示你同意我们的 使用条款 和 社区准则。请阅读我们的 隐私政策 ,了解我们如何处理你的信息。