简体中文界面。帖子、指南及政策正文保留原文;未对原文作自动翻译。

two tray demos, no fair comparison

TonyBowen · 2026年2月27日 10:10 UTC

已关闭
TO
TonyBowen
I cannot rank these cap-loading demonstrations. The UR5e video uses evenly spaced pockets; the other candidate uses our workshop tray with its awkward corner positions. Both finish. Neither shows the tray preparation.

17 条回复

LU
LucaArcher0352
回复 TonyBowen

Does the tidy tray arrive filled, Tony, or does someone move your caps into it first?

7
TO
TonyBowen

Someone transfers them from our tray. That task is absent from the video and the quoted cycle.

17
NI
NinaCarter1023
回复 TonyBowen

We tried a lovely presentation tray at a packing bench. It did its job, but it became a second place to put everything before putting everything in the box. Is that transfer done once per delivery or once per small order?

22
HA
HanaBrooks0796
回复 TonyBowen

The workshop tray may be the worse starting point, though. I would let a supplier propose a better tray, provided they show you what changing it actually costs.

12
TO
TonyBowen

Nina, each small order. The caps are already sorted into our tray before they reach this bench. Hana, I am willing to compare a new tray, but not a video that begins after the extra transfer.

10
ZA
ZaraBennett0743
回复 TonyBowen

We dropped a new-tray route when full-order costing exposed the preparation. Yours may be different. Could the upstream sorting use the new tray directly, rather than transferring twice?

21
LU
LucaArcher0352

Zara's question is worth asking before rejecting the tray, Tony, if the people sorting have any choice over what they use.

21
NI
NinaCarter1023

Also ask those people how they stack and return the trays. Our 'better' tray had a handle that made the normal return stack wobble. The drawing did not feature our irritated packer.

6
TO
TonyBowen

Sorting has looked at it. They need the existing tray for another check before it reaches us, so direct use of the proposed tray would mean changing that check too.

18
HA
HanaBrooks0796
回复 TonyBowen

Then the tray proposal has a larger scope than this bench. Could the supplier demonstrate with your tray before everyone redesigns sorting around its favourite pockets?

11
TO
TonyBowen

They have agreed to try the actual tray. I sent the corner-pocket examples as well as the easy middle ones.

11
ZA
ZaraBennett0743
回复 TonyBowen

Good. Does the other candidate finish those corner pockets without someone repositioning a cap?

0
LU
LucaArcher0352
回复 TonyBowen

And Tony, what happens to an incomplete tray at the end of an order? That's often the tray somebody forgets to film.

2
TO
TonyBowen

Zara, no repositioning in the supplied corner-pocket footage. Luca, the incomplete-tray ending is missing from both demonstrations. I have added it to the comparison request.

18
NI
NinaCarter1023
回复 TonyBowen

Thank you for asking sorting first. They usually get invited after somebody has already bought the tray.

20
TO
TonyBowen
回复 TonyBowen

The UR5e supplier's workshop-tray attempt could not complete one corner without manual help. We have removed that proposed tooling arrangement from the shortlist. The other candidate still owes us the incomplete-tray ending.

7
HA
HanaBrooks0796
回复 TonyBowen

A useful result even though it was a miss. Are they proposing different tooling, or leaving that option there?

15

讨论已关闭

此讨论已连续六个月没有活动,现已关闭新回复。 最后活动: .