简体中文界面。帖子、指南及政策正文保留原文;未对原文作自动翻译。

bracket alignment in restraint is not the released dimension

AaronChan1045 · 2026年6月13日 23:29 UTC

回复讨论
AA
AaronChan1045
I am reviewing our old gusseted angle-bracket records for a UR5e welding proposal, and the restrained alignment note sits beside failed released dimensions without explaining the correction between them; how should the fit-up, location and acceptance evidence be separated?

11 条回复

OM
OmarAllen0317

Find out what aligned meant before comparing numbers. A visual fit-up judgement and a released measurement might both be valid observations, but they don't measure the same thing.

18
BR
BrunoChen1148

And locate the correction in the route. I have seen a final inspection table become evidence of fixture performance after everybody forgot the hand work immediately before it.

16
AA
AaronChan1045

The restrained check used a fixture gauge, while the released measurement used the drawing datums; correction followed the first failed released check, but only the final accepted number survives in the sheet.

10
AA
AaronAdams0088

That is a useful thing to explain to whoever writes the new instructions, Aaron Chan, because otherwise the operator sees weld complete followed by accepted and has to discover the missing judgement themselves

22
TH
TheoArcher0410

I'd keep the failure note even without its number. It tells you the process included a correction decision. It doesn't tell you the size of the error or prove that every assembly needed the same work.

14
OM
OmarAllen0317

Bruno, did you recover any before-correction readings on yours, or did you need new samples?

1
BR
BrunoChen1148

New samples. The old gauge survived, but that did not recreate the missing readings or identify which components had gone into each old bracket.

4
TH
TheoArcher0410

That is the trap I'd avoid here too. Owning the measuring tool can feel like owning the evidence. It isn't, though it may help define a proper current-part comparison.

15
AA
AaronChan1045

Fabrication confirms the current gusset revision differs from the old one, so we are defining a current-assembly study rather than transferring the old correction allowance into the UR5e estimate as a known quantity.

14
AA
AaronAdams0088

Will that study include the untouched released assembly, Aaron Chan, before anyone applies the familiar correction and leaves you with another very tidy final result?

20
OM
OmarAllen0317

And price the inspection and possible correction as unresolved work until that scope is agreed. Unknown is inconvenient, but it isn't the same as no work needed.

10

参与讨论

欢迎来到 Application Robot

所有人都可以阅读论坛。登录或注册后即可发起讨论、回复或上传照片。

忘记密码?

注册账号即表示你同意我们的 使用条款 社区准则。请阅读我们的 隐私政策 ,了解我们如何处理你的信息。