Neither until they agree what it means. Renaming one signal is cheap; quietly keeping two meanings will follow you into every fault discussion.
简体中文界面。帖子、指南及政策正文保留原文;未对原文作自动翻译。
Two meanings of lathe ready
MinaAbbott0076 · 2026年3月8日 15:49 UTC
20 条回复
I'd be happier renaming both. Did either team actually describe what happens if the request is received but the loading area isn't available yet?
4分And please get the words on the eventual operator screen to match, otherwise a covering operator will inherit the argument without either drawing.
13分The machine drawing stays in preparation. The robot drawing has already advanced. They used the same arrow number as well, which hid the difference during our first meeting.
-1分Is another permission shown, or just that ready arrow?
17分Separate safety conditions are outside this process sketch. The missing process event is loading access available. I have asked both teams to show that explicitly, not treat request acceptance as a substitute.
8分Good. Now put a delayed preparation example through those arrows; the happy-path picture let both teams think they agreed.
8分Omar, I'd do the delay before anybody redraws the whole thing. Let each team say where it waits on the existing sketch and write down the disagreement there.
15分That's what I meant by through the arrows.
23分Mina, who is writing the screen wording once these events have names?
20分The integrator owns the screen text. I sent them the delayed-preparation example first. Thanks, Omar Ali; marking the two different waiting points made the call much shorter.
12分Amara, I have also put the screen wording on their list. It was absent from both teams' handover scope.
4分Does cancellation leave either team still waiting for the old request?
14分That's the awkward one. The request can disappear while preparation is still finishing. I don't know their interface, but I'd want to hear what each side thinks it is acknowledging then.
13分Have they agreed on the names yet, Mina?
9分Request accepted and loading access available are agreed. Cancellation exposed another difference: the machine team had retained the accepted request, while the robot sketch started a new exchange.
10分Will the operator see that an exchange was cancelled, or only that the cell is waiting?
3分Only waiting in the current screen draft. The integrator is revising it to distinguish the cancelled exchange. We have not settled how a fresh request is authorised after that.
10分Useful catch before implementation. Who owns that remaining decision?
12分I'd keep the cancellation example attached to the agreed names, Mina; it's the bit someone will otherwise drop when they tidy up the drawing.
21分讨论已关闭
此讨论已连续六个月没有活动,现已关闭新回复。 最后活动: .