The accepted bracket was checked after correction

CalebAllen0319 · 2025年6月26日 15:54 UTC

已关闭

主帖中文翻译暂不可用,以下显示英文原文;回复保留原文。 查看英文原文

CA
CalebAllen0319
Our FR10 welding proposal copies old fixture geometry. Final checks followed straightening. What can those records actually support?

11 条回复

YA
YasminBennett0702

Find the readings before straightening, if any, and tie them to individual brackets. Otherwise you only know what the corrected parts measured, not what the fixture produced.

20分
CA
CalebAllen0319

No pre-correction sheet found. There is a clamped alignment check, with different reference faces.

1分
JO
JoChan1114

Then why is someone comparing those dimensions? We found different datums hiding under the same word 'checked'. Get the old instruction beside the final one before spending another meeting subtracting unrelated numbers.

25分
DA
DavidAbbott0084

On another bracket review we found the fixture copy belonged to an older gusset. Which part and fixture revisions do your sheets actually identify?

3分
CA
CalebAllen0319

Bracket D on both. Fixture sheet says B; the proposed copy says A. I'm asking why.

25分
AD
AdaAllen0303

Could stores still have the B fixture drawing? I'd search that before asking someone to reverse-engineer the old photographs. Or rather, ask tooling who holds the controlled copy, not just the nearest folder

10分
CA
CalebAllen0319

Tooling found B. It includes a support absent from A. Purpose isn't described in the archived change note.

17分
YA
YasminBennett0702

Ask the old setter and welding lead about that support, with the drawing in front of them. I'd avoid transferring it as a requirement until its role is understood.

8分
JO
JoChan1114

And ask who did the straightening. The new cell doesn't get that labour for free just because it sits outside the fixture drawing. Does the proposed layout leave anywhere for it if it's still needed?

23分
DA
DavidAbbott0084

Caleb, keep the missing released measurement visible in the trial request. Discovering revision B is useful, but you still haven't found an untouched bracket result to compare.

20分
CA
CalebAllen0319
回复 JoChan1114

Layout assumed no straightening. That assumption is on hold; current-part trial still needs welding and quality agreement.

18分

讨论已关闭

此讨论已连续六个月没有活动,现已关闭新回复。 最后活动: .