I would look at the actual seating and grip before choosing a correction. Have maintenance compare the intended finger pair, contact wear, mounting and tray location, with the recent service and point-change history available. Looking unchanged from above isn't a tray-location check.
Get that intended assembly identified before ordering another finger. Keep the measured difference with the service record and point versions. Then the responsible tooling and controls people can review the physical correction and which edits still belong with it.