FR5 carton demo used the glossy print, our next delivery is uncoated

ThomasBell0625 · 14 Mar 2026, 17:50 UTC

Closed
TH
ThomasBell0625
Supplier demonstrated the glossy carton. Our order mixes that finish with uncoated board, and the quote calls both equivalent.

14 replies

OL
OliverBrooks0798
Replying to ThomasBell0625

Has packaging confirmed they are the same construction apart from the print finish?

18points
TH
ThomasBell0625
Replying to OliverBrooks0798

No. Same size, two suppliers. I shouldn't have called finish the only difference.

7points
HA
HazelBrown0919
Replying to ThomasBell0625

Start with the two actual packed constructions, then. Photograph the intended contacts over the seams and print, and ask the tool supplier to explain what it has assessed on each.

19points
CA
CallumAdams0099
Replying to ThomasBell0625

Are both carton types meant to arrive mixed at the transfer station, or does packing change over between them? That affects the everyday job.

3points
TH
ThomasBell0625
Replying to CallumAdams0099

Mixed within an order. Packers use whichever approved carton stock is at the bench.

10points
MA
MayaAllen0301
Replying to ThomasBell0625

Then don't accept a trial that has someone sort the boxes first unless that becomes an actual costed task; our quote comparison changed completely once we counted preparation.

3points
OL
OliverBrooks0798
Replying to HazelBrown0919

Does the proposed tool use one contact arrangement for both constructions?

19points
HA
HazelBrown0919
Replying to MayaAllen0301

Maya, sorting could be an option, though I agree it can't appear as free help. Thomas needs the mixed case assessed before deciding whether a separate route is worth pricing.

11points
TH
ThomasBell0625
Replying to OliverBrooks0798

Oliver, yes, one arrangement. Supplier now wants packed samples of both types instead of judging the photographs.

14points
CA
CallumAdams0099
Replying to ThomasBell0625

Good. Keep the sample construction references in the trial report so purchasing can tell whether a later carton substitution needs another look.

17points
MA
MayaAllen0301
Replying to HazelBrown0919

Hazel, fair enough. I meant no hidden sorting, not that every mixed order must stay mixed forever.

15points
OL
OliverBrooks0798
Replying to ThomasBell0625

Who is choosing the ordinary seam and tape variation within those samples?

21points
TH
ThomasBell0625
Replying to OliverBrooks0798

Packaging chose them. Samples sent, including the uncoated carton with its ordinary tape overlap; no trial result yet.

-1points
HA
HazelBrown0919
Replying to ThomasBell0625

Ask them to show the mixed sequence through placement and release when they report back. Separate successful lifts will not tell you how their proposed station handles the change between cartons.

21points

Discussion closed

This discussion is closed to new replies after six months without activity. Last activity: .