The faster puck demo starts with somebody else's lovely tray

PriyaChan1090 · 10 May 2026, 03:20 UTC

Reply to discussion
PR
PriyaChan1090
Our FR10 candidate looks slower with the workshop tray, while the other demo starts with every puck neatly separated in a new insert; I'm including preparation time now, but how do I compare the handling without confusing a better tray with a better arm?

7 replies

JA
JackBennett0776
Replying to PriyaChan1090

Did both demonstrations finish in your actual receiving fixture?

21 points
PR
PriyaChan1090
Replying to JackBennett0776

No, second supplier used a flat test pocket instead of our fixture, so the easy starting tray isn't even the only difference.

14 points
FE
FelixAdams0110
Replying to PriyaChan1090

Then compare complete jobs before comparing speeds. Send the same incoming tray, pucks and receiving requirement to both, and let each explain any proposed changes. A new insert might be worthwhile; it just needs its preparation, exchanges and cost visible instead of appearing as a free improvement.

6 points
JA
JackBennett0776
Replying to PriyaChan1090

Include release into the fixture. A neat pickup does not answer that part.

3 points
PR
PriyaChan1090
Replying to FelixAdams0110

Both now have the same job brief; second supplier needs a different finger detail for our receiver and has withdrawn the old cycle figure, first supplier is repeating with the awkward tray positions included.

5 points
FE
FelixAdams0110
Replying to PriyaChan1090

Good. I'd ask for the unsuccessful positions as well as the edited video, Priya; you learn more from why someone intervened than from the next ten effortless placements.

11 points
JA
JackBennett0776
Replying to PriyaChan1090

Has either repeat established a complete transfer yet?

13 points

Add to the discussion

Welcome to Application Robot

Everyone can read the forum. Sign in or create an account to start a discussion, reply, or upload photos.

Forgot your password?

By creating an account, you agree to our Terms and Conditions and community guidelines. Read our Privacy Policy for how your information is handled.