GabrielChen1149 · 3 Jun 2025, 02:42 UTC
Don't invent one, let packaging assess the real filled cases in each arrangement and give you the conditions their answer applies to, because a high score in your spreadsheet won't hold a carton up
3 pointsPackaging wants sample stacks, which I can arrange, but the tool supplier wants one pattern chosen before they'll check the fingers
9 pointsThey can surely flag an obvious access clash on two sketches without designing the whole gripper twice? I'd ask what they actually need paid for at this stage.
16 pointsThey'll do an outline review of both, not a detailed tool design, which is enough to stop us picking something they already know won't work
2 pointsPut pallet and transport costs beside each option. Fewer cartons may cost more to ship. I would leave packaging approval as a requirement, not convert it into points.
12 pointsWe found our comparison had different incoming conditions attached to each proposal. Do both patterns use the same carton and packing revision?
7 pointsYes, same current carton and insert, and packaging has confirmed the samples match; I've kept empty display cases away from the review this time
17 pointsBring whoever actually dispatches the part-filled pallets too, they may be more interested in your awkward final few boxes than the perfect full stack on the front page
10 pointsAlso, can either option use the pallets you already buy? A special pallet can turn a small layout win into a regular purchasing nuisance.
1 pointsBoth fit the current pallet footprint, though I haven't checked how the carton supports line up with its deck boards
4 pointsFootprint alone leaves that unanswered. Include the actual board layout in the support drawing.
4 pointsAnd don't solve the upper layer then forget the first layer, the pallet itself seems to vanish from these discussions remarkably often
17 pointsOur first-layer pads line up on one pallet type in stores but not the other, so I'm glad I hadn't circulated the cost comparison as finished
13 pointsHow are the two pallet types identified when they reach packing? I'm wondering whether the operator could tell which one your approved drawing expects.
23 pointsDifferent stock references, but no clear distinction on the packing screen, so the packing lead wants that sorted before either arrangement is introduced
19 pointsI would include the actual pallets in the sample review, with those references attached. It is easy for a correct stock code to accompany the wrong physical example.
18 pointsUpdate the cost for the specified pallet only. Using the cheaper mixed-stock average would understate the arrangement you are actually considering.
13 pointsThanks, Aaron, that average was exactly what I had used; I've changed the comparison and left both patterns pending the packaging and tool reviews
7 pointsThis discussion is closed to new replies after six months without activity. Last activity: .