Will the FR10 carton tool need our packers to flatten every lid?

AnilAli0201 · 10 Mar 2026, 15:48 UTC

Closed
AN
AnilAli0201
Our supplier pressed the carton lid flat before its vacuum demo, but ours leave packing slightly crowned.

21 replies

NI
NinaBrown0936
Replying to AnilAli0201

We had a demo that quietly depended on somebody arranging the work first. Ask them to repeat with cartons straight from your packing process, and leave that pressing step visible if they still need it.

10points
OM
OmarBell0665
Replying to AnilAli0201

Is the crown accepted by your packaging team, Anil? You want the normal range in the trial, not an argument later about whether your samples were faulty.

8points
AN
AnilAli0201
Replying to OmarBell0665

Packaging accepts these cartons. The demo sample had the same board but different contents.

17points
LU
LuisBarnes0608
Replying to AnilAli0201

Different contents can change what supports the top. Send packed samples, with packaging deciding which ordinary variations need to be represented.

10points
CA
CalebChan1102
Replying to AnilAli0201

Who selected the first sample?

25points
AN
AnilAli0201
Replying to CalebChan1102

I sent an empty carton. That part was my mistake; packed samples are now being arranged.

5points
NI
NinaBrown0936
Replying to AnilAli0201

Easy mistake. Make the seam and tape positions ordinary too. A packed sample beautifully retaped for the camera would waste the second trip.

7points
OM
OmarBell0665
Replying to NinaBrown0936

Nina, I'd ask for the normal packing method rather than insist on one particular seam position; the permitted variation is what the tool has to handle.

24points
AN
AnilAli0201
Replying to AnilAli0201

Packed samples arrived with the supplier. Packaging included both ordinary tape positions and the accepted crown variation.

-1points
CA
CalebChan1102
Replying to AnilAli0201

Are they demonstrating placement in your dispatch lane too?

20points
LU
LuisBarnes0608
Replying to CalebChan1102

Caleb's point matters. My separate panel proposal acquired a manual preparation job once we asked for the whole transfer. Get the arrival and departure shown as well as the lift.

22points
NI
NinaBrown0936
Replying to OmarBell0665

Omar, yes, ordinary variation. I was worried about somebody preparing an especially neat replacement for the empty box.

25points
AN
AnilAli0201
Replying to LuisBarnes0608

Caleb, they have our lane mock-up. Luis, the trial request includes release and return, with preparation counted.

17points
OM
OmarBell0665
Replying to AnilAli0201

Thanks for checking the crown with packaging early. That should save a fairly pointless round of blaming your cartons.

7points
AN
AnilAli0201
Replying to AnilAli0201

Trial stopped on the more crowned cartons. Supplier proposes manual flattening and a separate second attempt area.

16points
LU
LuisBarnes0608
Replying to AnilAli0201

Who would cover both tasks? That's a substantially different packing job, especially if the same person still feeds the station.

17points
CA
CalebChan1102
Replying to AnilAli0201

Has packaging accepted flattening those packed cartons?

15points
NI
NinaBrown0936
Replying to AnilAli0201

I'd price another handling concept before spending much on a second-attempt area. You're adding labour to make this particular tool look viable.

16points
AN
AnilAli0201
Replying to CalebChan1102

Packaging rejected the flattening step for these contents. We've stopped this tool trial and left the transfer manual.

15points
NI
NinaBrown0936
Replying to AnilAli0201

Sensible place to stop. Has the supplier removed the original successful-trial wording from their proposal?

13points

Discussion closed

This discussion is closed to new replies after six months without activity. Last activity: .