Enough reach, incomplete drawing

FelixBarnes0545 · 29 May 2026, 05:30 UTC

Reply to discussion
FE
FelixBarnes0545
Our proposed use for Fairino FR10 is finished blank removal with a cylindrical aluminum blank in a compact machining workshop, with 102 planned. The reach sketch suggests the fixture is accessible, but it includes neither the gripper body nor the open machine door. I need a fuller access check to inform our choice of arm.

18 replies

LI
LiamAllen0316
Replying to FelixBarnes0545

Got measured outlines for the opening and gripper? An offline layout might catch what the reach circle misses.

17 points
FE
FelixBarnes0545
Replying to LiamAllen0316

After comparing the outlines, I found that the proposed approach overlaps the door handle even though the workpiece itself clears. That explains the misleadingly comfortable result in my initial sketch.

15 points
LI
LiamAllen0316
Replying to FelixBarnes0545

Use that measured layout to review the complete approach and retreat offline. Include the tool, cables and service access, then ask the integrator to assess a revised mounting arrangement.

10 points
FE
FelixBarnes0545
Replying to LiamAllen0316

The buyer has suggested choosing a larger arm. I'm unsure whether that would address the access issue or simply increase our purchase while leaving the obstruction unresolved.

14 points
LI
LiamAllen0316
Replying to FelixBarnes0545

A larger arm should give you more mounting freedom, so that could be the easiest route to investigate.

17 points
DA
DanielBrown0913
Replying to LiamAllen0316

@LiamAllen0316 Bigger could bring another obstruction. Extra reach won't shrink the gripper past that handle.

12 points
LI
LiamAllen0316
Replying to DanielBrown0913

Yes, I made that sound more certain than it's. Compare candidate geometry in the measured layout; a larger arm is only useful if the complete approach improves.

7 points
LE
LeahAli0234
Replying to LiamAllen0316

@LiamAllen0316 On our separate machine job, the first pedestal position blocked a maintenance panel. The transfer looked excellent until the maintenance person asked how they'd open it.

21 points
FE
FelixBarnes0545
Replying to LeahAli0234

Your example prompted me to compare our proposed pedestal with the service panel opening. That revealed another overlap to correct in the layout.

17 points
MA
MayaParts
Replying to FelixBarnes0545

@FelixBarnes0545 Would making the pedestal removable address service access, or would restoring its position introduce a further setup requirement to evaluate?

20 points
LI
LiamAllen0316
Replying to MayaParts

A removable base adds relocation and installation checks to the work. Have the integrator weigh that against keeping normal service access clear in the layout.

6 points
FE
FelixBarnes0545
Replying to LiamAllen0316

The fixture requires a straight approach segment. Should we establish that constraint in the model before exploring alternative positions for the robot base?

13 points
LI
LiamAllen0316
Replying to FelixBarnes0545

Yes. Include the required entry direction and withdrawal conditions, not just an end pose. A reachable point can still have no usable approach with the proposed tool.

11 points
LE
LeahAli0234
Replying to LiamAllen0316

@LiamAllen0316 For our machine, withdrawal with a held workpiece needed a different route from entry. The empty-tool model made the clearance look much better than it was.

23 points
FE
FelixBarnes0545
Replying to LeahAli0234

I'll include empty and loaded tool outlines. We also need to agree who owns the machine signals; that part of the quote is vague.

18 points
DA
DanielBrown0913
Replying to FelixBarnes0545

Name whoever owns the interface work. Otherwise the robot and machine contacts can both think the other has covered fixture state and permission to enter.

12 points
FE
FelixBarnes0545
Replying to DanielBrown0913

Identifying the handle obstruction has helped, but we still need an assessed layout that addresses it. We're keeping the arm under consideration without making a purchase decision.

11 points
LI
LiamAllen0316
Replying to FelixBarnes0545

Having a specific access issue to resolve is progress; it doesn't require choosing the arm yet.

25 points

Add to the discussion

Welcome to Application Robot

Everyone can read the forum. Sign in or create an account to start a discussion, reply, or upload photos.

Forgot your password?

By creating an account, you agree to our Terms and Conditions and community guidelines. Read our Privacy Policy for how your information is handled.