Bracket contact at the nest corner

HassanBennett0704 · 3 Mar 2026, 21:21 UTC

Closed
HA
HassanBennett0704
One of our inspection brackets sits flat in the proposed FR5 nest; another catches near a corner before reaching the pads. The model contacts several bracket faces and looks very convincing. The suggestion is a stronger clamp. I would rather find out what it is being asked to overcome before we pay for that.

14 replies

CH
ChloeBrooks0831
Replying to HassanBennett0704

Have both brackets been checked against the drawing?

14points
HA
HassanBennett0704
Replying to ChloeBrooks0831

Yes. Quality accepts both, though they are not identical at that corner. I have asked the fixture designer to look at the actual contact with the samples.

4points
FI
FionaBarnes0586
Replying to HassanBennett0704

Who suggested the stronger clamp?

20points
HA
HassanArcher0356
Replying to HassanBennett0704

Accepted variation needs to fit the locating scheme without the clamp forcing the bracket into a different shape; the designer should identify intended contacts and accidental ones.

10points
FA
FarahCarter1026
Replying to HassanBennett0704

Look at what catches before blaming that corner dimension. It might be a nearby lead-in or fixing. Has anyone actually seen the first contact?

23points
HA
HassanBennett0704
Replying to FarahCarter1026

Fiona, our production lead suggested the clamp, not the designer. Farah, the designer has now shown the first contact: an internal nest radius catches one bracket before its foot reaches the pad.

12points
FI
FionaBarnes0586
Replying to HassanBennett0704

Did the designer propose a relief there?

10points
CH
ChloeBrooks0831
Replying to FionaBarnes0586

Will the intended locating faces stay unchanged?

12points
HA
HassanArcher0356
Replying to FionaBarnes0586

A relief may be appropriate, but that is the designer's decision after checking the accepted bracket range, not an invitation to file the corner until this one sample fits.

14points
HA
HassanBennett0704
Replying to ChloeBrooks0831

The designer proposed a local clearance change that leaves the locating pads and faces intact. It is going into the prototype nest drawing. No stronger clamp in the revision.

15points
FA
FarahCarter1026
Replying to HassanBennett0704

That sounds more useful. Does the loader have a way to recognise proper seating, rather than just seeing the top look level?

16points
HA
HassanBennett0704
Replying to FarahCarter1026

Yes, the revised view shows the pad contacts from the loading side. We have had the prototype changed and quality is checking the retained bracket range in it.

17points
HA
HassanBennett0704
Replying to FarahCarter1026

The checked brackets now reach the intended contacts without rocking or being pulled down by the clamp. Quality accepted the seating comparison and the drawing has been updated. Thanks, Farah, the first-contact question stopped us arguing about which bracket looked odd.

8points
FI
FionaBarnes0586
Replying to HassanBennett0704

Did the production lead keep the stronger-clamp quote as a souvenir?

20points

Discussion closed

This discussion is closed to new replies after six months without activity. Last activity: .