The new bracket layout loses a bench the old route still uses

AmaraCarter1035 · 26 Jun 2025, 04:32 UTC

Closed
AM
AmaraCarter1035
Our FR10 welding proposal has removed the correction bench from the floor plan, but the old bracket records only pass after that bench, so I'm asking who decided its work would disappear

19 replies

SA
SamBarnes0594
Replying to AmaraCarter1035

Did the layout owner have the old route description, or only the final accepted drawing requirement?

8 points
AM
AmaraCarter1035
Replying to SamBarnes0594

Only the final requirement and a cycle figure from before the bench, which makes the proposed saving look rather less mysterious

23 points
NI
NinaAllen0327
Replying to AmaraCarter1035

Then reopen the layout assumption before everyone starts designing around the empty space. You can investigate whether the bench is needed without pretending the answer already exists

20 points
SA
SaraCarter0983
Replying to AmaraCarter1035

Who knows what happens at that bench?

6 points
AM
AmaraCarter1035
Replying to SaraCarter0983

The fabricator calls it straighten and check, but the written route doesn't say what gets measured before he starts

5 points
NI
NinaCarter1023
Replying to AmaraCarter1035

Our packing route once hid a whole inspection under tidy up, so I'd ask him to walk through a normal example in words, including what makes him decide it needs correction rather than assuming everyone means the same operation.

20 points
SA
SamBarnes0594
Replying to AmaraCarter1035

Can quality identify the acceptance check he uses after correction, including the drawing revision?

13 points
AM
AmaraCarter1035
Replying to SamBarnes0594

Quality says released flange height to assembly revision D, current job is F; they are comparing the changes before copying any of those numbers

5 points
NI
NinaAllen0327
Replying to AmaraCarter1035

Keep the old fixture revision in that comparison too. The component drawing can change while the fixture is quietly altered at the bench

6 points
AM
AmaraCarter1035
Replying to NinaAllen0327

Found fixture revision B in the old job packet, plus an unnumbered sketch for an extra stop, so we don't yet know which actual arrangement produced the accepted parts

11 points
SA
SaraCarter0983
Replying to AmaraCarter1035

Can the old setter recognise the extra stop?

24 points
AM
AmaraCarter1035
Replying to SaraCarter0983

He's still here and recognised the sketch, says it was tried then removed because some brackets wouldn't seat; that's recollection, not a signed change record

21 points
NI
NinaCarter1023
Replying to AmaraCarter1035

Did he say which samples would not seat? A difference between component batches could be useful to investigate, even if his memory cannot establish the final fixture configuration.

8 points
AM
AmaraCarter1035
Replying to NinaCarter1023

He remembers a different gusset supply, no batch number, so I'm keeping that as a question for the incoming-part review rather than writing it down as the cause

15 points
SA
SamBarnes0594
Replying to AmaraCarter1035

Who owns the current-part review now, including the measurements before any correction?

25 points
NI
NinaAllen0327
Replying to SamBarnes0594

I'd have the fabrication and quality people define it together. A fixture designer alone shouldn't be left to guess both what arrives and what counts as an acceptable released bracket

9 points
AM
AmaraCarter1035
Replying to SamBarnes0594

Fabrication lead is organising it with quality and the fixture designer; purchasing has marked the cycle estimate provisional and the bench space stays in the planning comparison for now

20 points
SA
SaraCarter0983
Replying to AmaraCarter1035

Thanks for keeping the floor-plan answer provisional too.

12 points
NI
NinaCarter1023
Replying to AmaraCarter1035

Let us know what the current samples show. I'm especially interested whether the seating concern repeats with known component identities, rather than only in the old setter's memory.

25 points

Discussion closed

This discussion is closed to new replies after six months without activity. Last activity: .