fr5 adapter drawing does not match the delivered assembly

PavelBaker0440 · 8 Apr 2026, 22:17 UTC

Closed
PA
PavelBaker0440
Our tooling is still unfitted after fifty-two days of equivalence replies. The delivered FR5 package has a different label suffix and an adapter with a different connection position from the drawing the seller accepted. Which identified comparison should I require?

12 replies

OS
OscarAbbott0010
Replying to PavelBaker0440

Put the accepted drawing and delivered assembly identities side by side, then ask the seller to identify the supplied adapter drawing. Equivalent needs an explanation here, especially with the connection moved.

9points
PA
PavelBaker0440
Replying to OscarAbbott0010

They have identified the supplied drawing. It is a deeper adapter, with the connection on another face. Their reply still says our tool should fit.

-1points
CH
ChloeBaker0483
Replying to PavelBaker0440

Send the whole tool view back with it. A flange lining up doesn't tell them where your fittings and cables end up.

15points
PA
PavelBaker0440
Replying to ChloeBaker0483

Our tool designer has overlaid both adapters with the complete tool. The supplied connection occupies the space used by our fixture-side bracket.

7points
OS
OscarAbbott0010
Replying to PavelBaker0440

That gives them an actual clash to answer. Have you asked for the originally agreed adapter as one option, instead of treating a tooling redesign as already decided?

18points
SA
SaraChan1070
Replying to PavelBaker0440

Who would support the modified assembly if they propose moving your bracket? That responsibility can get lost between the seller and your tool designer.

3points
PA
PavelBaker0440
Replying to OscarAbbott0010

Oscar, the agreed adapter is our requested remedy. Sara, no one has accepted support responsibility for a redesign, and we have not authorised one.

1points
CH
ChloeBaker0483
Replying to PavelBaker0440

Good. I've seen a suggestion turn into customer requested change just because nobody answered that bit explicitly.

5points
AN
AnilBell0636
Replying to PavelBaker0440

Get the complete proposed arrangement assessed before choosing a substitute. Moving the connection or adding another plate can change the tool position, carried mass and load distribution as well as access. Your designer needs the actual adapter identity and data, not a promise that the holes match. I'd price the original agreed supply and any assessed alternative separately, including installation, application checks and support. Otherwise you can end up paying to make the delivered difference disappear while the order still looks fully satisfied.

19points
OS
OscarAbbott0010
Replying to AnilBell0636

And ask whether the agreed adapter is available. I mean the identified item, not another suitable-adapter description that starts this conversation again.

5points
PA
PavelBaker0440
Replying to OscarAbbott0010

Seller cannot offer a date for the agreed adapter. Purchasing has requested a return proposal with packing and cost responsibilities specified; we are not proceeding with the tooling redesign.

16points
SA
SaraChan1070
Replying to PavelBaker0440

Has the seller agreed to that return, or is the proposal still outstanding? Keep the collection arrangements separate until there is an actual agreement.

16points

Discussion closed

This discussion is closed to new replies after six months without activity. Last activity: .