Cannot let the FR10 startup helper retry every pending entry

TheoBarnes0584 · 12 Oct 2025, 00:47 UTC

Closed
TH
TheoBarnes0584
Our earlier delayed-result tests taught me not to let one attempt finish another. I've found a separate hole in this startup helper: pending means both never sent and sent with no saved result. It resubmits both after a crash. I've stopped that path in the test build, but what should recovery know before retrying the uncertain bracket check?

4 replies

RE
RebeccaChan1126
Replying to TheoBarnes0584

Its original attempt identity and whatever the receiving side retained about it. Don't manufacture a fresh identity just because the file lacks a result. You could give an already completed inspection a convincing new label.

5 points
TH
TheoBarnes0584
Replying to RebeccaChan1126

We save the attempt ID before sending, so that part survives. But the helper creates a new one for every retry. The fix needs to query or reconcile the old attempt, not jump straight to another request.

18 points
RE
RebeccaChan1126
Replying to TheoBarnes0584

Yes. And if the old outcome cannot be established, leave it unknown for an authorised decision. Don't let a failed query become your evidence that the original inspection never happened.

4 points
LU
LucaAllen0265
Replying to TheoBarnes0584

Did you include a crash after the receiver completed but before your local save? Interested whether the revised startup presents that as uncertain rather than quietly adding it to the work queue again.

12 points

Discussion closed

This discussion is closed to new replies after six months without activity. Last activity: .