Why is the delivered UR5e adapter called equivalent without a drawing comparison?

JackBarnes0602 · 21 Aug 2026, 11:59 UTC

Reply to discussion
JA
JackBarnes0602
The seller in China confirmed our fixture drawing before we ordered the UR5e configuration. Delivery has a different label suffix and a visibly different interface around the flange adapter. Twenty-one days awaiting their comparison. Tooling remains unfitted; I need evidence of applicability, not a general equivalence assurance.

17 replies

AM
AmyAdams0119
Replying to JackBarnes0602

Separate the label difference from the interface difference in your enquiry. The suffix may have an explanation that says nothing about whether your tooling fits the adapter they actually supplied.

22 points
DI
DineshBarnes0560
Replying to JackBarnes0602

Can you identify the adapter itself from the delivered records, not just the arm?

13 points
SA
SaraChen1157
Replying to AmyAdams0119

Keep the confirmed drawing revision beside the delivery views. Similarity to a catalogue picture will not establish which configuration they agreed to supply.

11 points
JA
JackBarnes0602
Replying to DineshBarnes0560

The receipt names the arm but gives no separate adapter reference. I've sent the confirmed drawing revision and marked the visible locating-face difference without trying to fit our tooling.

16 points
CA
CarlaBarnes0575
Replying to JackBarnes0602

Ask for an adapter drawing and supplied reference. Equivalent needs to answer the fitter's interface question, not just the order label.

18 points
AM
AmyAdams0119
Replying to CarlaBarnes0575

Have your tooling reviewer name the relevant locating, fastening and resulting tool-position requirements. That gives the seller a concrete comparison to answer, and may reveal differences that a front photograph cannot show.

18 points
JA
JackBarnes0602
Replying to AmyAdams0119

Our reviewer has listed those requirements, including the locating shoulder and clearance behind the plate. Seller says the suffix is a supply revision, but still has not identified the adapter drawing.

20 points
SA
SaraChen1157
Replying to JackBarnes0602

That answers their explanation of the suffix only. I would leave the visible interface discrepancy as its own unresolved line.

4 points
DI
DineshBarnes0560
Replying to JackBarnes0602

And keep stores from assigning the ordered adapter reference to the delivered one while identification is open.

5 points
CA
CarlaBarnes0575
Replying to JackBarnes0602

Has purchasing asked who owns the technical answer, rather than another forwarded equivalence message?

22 points
JA
JackBarnes0602
Replying to CarlaBarnes0575

A technical contact has now supplied the delivered adapter drawing. Our reviewer found its shoulder conflicts with the recess in our confirmed fixture interface; it is not suitable as supplied for this tool.

18 points
AM
AmyAdams0119
Replying to JackBarnes0602

That is the finding to put back to the seller. Ask them to propose how they will meet the confirmed interface, with the technical comparison and any commercial terms explicit; do not silently turn it into your workshop's modification job.

24 points
JA
JackBarnes0602
Replying to AmyAdams0119

They proposed supplying a different adapter. It has not shipped, and I have asked for its drawing before accepting the proposal. No agreement to modify our fixture.

12 points
DI
DineshBarnes0560
Replying to JackBarnes0602

Keep the unsuitable adapter identified and segregated, so the alternative does not erase what actually arrived.

14 points
SA
SaraChen1157
Replying to JackBarnes0602

Does the proposal address the added adapter's tool position and service access, or only the mating face?

14 points
JA
JackBarnes0602
Replying to AmyAdams0119

Not yet. Those are on the reviewer list with the load implications and fastening details. Thanks, Amy; we have a specific confirmed mismatch now, but the replacement proposal still needs assessment and agreed supply terms.

5 points
CA
CarlaBarnes0575
Replying to JackBarnes0602

Then tooling stays unfitted. A plausible replacement offer is progress, not proof the purchased configuration is ready.

8 points

Add to the discussion

Welcome to Application Robot

Everyone can read the forum. Sign in or create an account to start a discussion, reply, or upload photos.

Forgot your password?

By creating an account, you agree to our Terms and Conditions and community guidelines. Read our Privacy Policy for how your information is handled.