Who checks FR10 withdrawal after the brass blank clears the fixture?

MiaAdams0122 · 1 Dec 2025, 06:36 UTC

Closed
MI
MiaAdams0122
I have requested the full held assembly for this brass-blank review. The revised FR10 sketch now shows the gripper at pickup, but withdrawal still ignores the open mill door. Who should own that remaining access check?

10 replies

JA
JasperAbbott0029
Replying to MiaAdams0122

The integrator should coordinate it with the machine and tooling owners. I'd ask for the actual door position and complete held tool through withdrawal, not another reach arrow.

23 points
MI
MiaAdams0122
Replying to JasperAbbott0029

They propose moving the stand outward. Machine owner hasn't reviewed it. I have asked for both the present candidate and proposed position in the same comparison.

3 points
JO
JoFixtures
Replying to MiaAdams0122

Keep the adapter in both assemblies too, because moving the stand to clear a missing chunk of tool is a surprisingly expensive way to discover the export was incomplete

12 points
WI
WillAllen0313
Replying to MiaAdams0122

And keep the blank held in its proposed orientation. We had an access picture that looked generous because the part had been turned to face the reader. The attractive view was not the grip position the fixture required.

16 points
MI
MiaAdams0122
Replying to WillAllen0313

Jo, adapter is included in the new export. Will, held orientation matches the proposed grip. The door sweep and handle are still the missing geometry; I am not filling those in by eye.

18 points
JA
JasperAbbott0029
Replying to WillAllen0313

Will, did correcting that view rule out your location, or did tooling have a workable alternative? Curious how much the missing orientation changed the decision.

-2 points
WI
WillAllen0313
Replying to JasperAbbott0029

It ruled out that candidate in our comparison. We kept the other location for a fuller review. Not saying Mia's will do the same; just don't let presentation in the drawing choose the answer.

18 points
JO
JoFixtures
Replying to MiaAdams0122

Ask who updates the operator access and maintenance layout if the farther stand survives, Mia, because the robot's route isn't the only route that moves with it

7 points
MI
MiaAdams0122
Replying to JoFixtures

Integrator owns the combined layout with our setter and maintenance lead reviewing it. The original position now has a documented withdrawal conflict; the farther candidate remains under review, not selected.

17 points
JA
JasperAbbott0029
Replying to MiaAdams0122

Has the farther candidate cleared those checks now, Mia? Interested whether you kept this arm in the comparison or still have the whole layout undecided.

15 points

Discussion closed

This discussion is closed to new replies after six months without activity. Last activity: .