Carton corners over gaps in the FR5 pallet proposal

RebeccaBrooks0865 · 15 Aug 2026, 04:22 UTC

Reply to discussion
RE
RebeccaBrooks0865
The alternating layers fill our pallet drawing neatly. Looking closer, some turned product boxes put their preferred support faces above gaps. I'm reviewing this FR5 packing proposal and would like packaging and tooling to resolve the same version, not send two unrelated approvals. Where should the comparison start?

17 replies

CA
CarlaBrown0923
Replying to RebeccaBrooks0865

Start with filled boxes and their bearing requirements. A rectangle on a pallet doesn't tell packaging which bit of the contents is loading the carton wall.

5 points
WI
WillCarter1009
Replying to CarlaBrown0923

Include the build sequence, too. I keep seeing finished layers assessed while the partly built ones disappear from the discussion.

7 points
MI
MinaBrooks0859
Replying to RebeccaBrooks0865

Try fewer boxes as a candidate. Losing a little capacity might be cheaper than trying to make this exact picture work.

9 points
RO
RosaBrown0901
Replying to MinaBrooks0859

Mina, fewer boxes can also leave larger gaps. I would compare bearing areas for both candidates before treating the lower count as the easy option. It may help the tool without helping the box.

7 points
RE
RebeccaBrooks0865
Replying to RosaBrown0901

I've asked for that comparison. Packaging has the box construction now, and I have numbered the turned positions on the current layout. The alternative isn't a recommendation yet.

1 points
OL
OliverAdams0102
Replying to WillCarter1009

Who handles a partly completed pallet at a shift change? That condition needs an owner, not just a drawing note

5 points
EL
ElliotAli0248
Replying to OliverAdams0102

Dispatch may move those partial pallets. Ask them before assuming they remain at the cell.

11 points
MI
MinaBrooks0859
Replying to RosaBrown0901

Fair correction, Rosa. I was thinking finger access, not claiming fewer cartons support each other better.

0 points
VA
Val_Carr
Replying to WillCarter1009

Would numbered placement stages help here? Tool release clearance can change when the neighbouring box is already present. Keep those stages with the support overlay.

9 points
RE
RebeccaBrooks0865
Replying to ElliotAli0248

Dispatch does move partial pallets. Packaging has now ruled out two turned positions for this filled-box construction. The lower-count drawing still has one of them, so it isn't our answer either.

5 points
WI
WillCarter1009
Replying to RebeccaBrooks0865

That saves assessing two unsuitable drawings as if they're finalists. Can packaging mark the acceptable bearing arrangement for the next layout?

21 points
CA
CarlaBrown0923
Replying to WillCarter1009

They should state the requirements, Will. I'd avoid asking them to design the robot pattern unless that really is their role.

7 points
OL
OliverAdams0102
Replying to RebeccaBrooks0865

And nobody has answered the shift-change responsibility yet. Dispatch moving it does not name who releases it for movement

16 points
RE
RebeccaBrooks0865
Replying to OliverAdams0102

Warehouse supervisor owns that decision. We've added the partial-pallet condition to their review, and the layout designer has packaging's marked exclusions. Tool supplier is waiting for the revised sequence.

21 points
WI
WillCarter1009
Replying to CarlaBrown0923

Carla, requirements was what I meant. Thanks for catching it; I don't want packaging silently inheriting the whole layout job.

8 points
RE
RebeccaBrooks0865
Replying to RebeccaBrooks0865

The two old drawings are withdrawn from the sign-off pack. Revised candidate due next week. This review has definitely changed the proposal, but we don't have a usable pattern to approve yet.

1 points
EL
ElliotAli0248
Replying to RebeccaBrooks0865

Interested in the partial-pallet result when that comes back. Full layers get all the attention.

18 points

Add to the discussion

Welcome to Application Robot

Everyone can read the forum. Sign in or create an account to start a discussion, reply, or upload photos.

Forgot your password?

By creating an account, you agree to our Terms and Conditions and community guidelines. Read our Privacy Policy for how your information is handled.