Our FR5 saved pocket advances before placement is confirmed

JackChan1124 · 14 Jan 2026, 17:45 UTC

Closed
JA
JackChan1124
Saved pocket advances on the place request. Stop before release leaves a spacer held and the count ahead

5 replies

FA
FarahAllen0330
Replying to JackChan1124

The request cannot stand in for a completed transfer; have the designer distinguish intended pocket, held part and confirmed placement, including what survives an interruption between confirmation and saving.

12 points
JA
JackChan1124
Replying to FarahAllen0330

Agreed. Moving the save later still leaves a gap if placement happens and the save fails

8 points
FA
FarahAllen0330
Replying to JackChan1124

Yes, so retain enough identified transfer state to reconcile that gap, and leave uncertain physical outcomes for the authorised recovery process rather than guessing from the saved pocket.

10 points
JA
JackChan1124
Replying to FarahAllen0330

Offline case added: placement completed, save failed, then two restarts. It must stay unresolved through both

14 points
FA
FarahAllen0330
Replying to JackChan1124

Include the receiving tray identity in that case too, because a pocket number alone can look consistent after somebody has exchanged the tray.

15 points

Discussion closed

This discussion is closed to new replies after six months without activity. Last activity: .