Our bracket gets a pass only after the bit nobody priced

AmaraCarter1035 · 19 Nov 2025, 00:35 UTC

Closed
AM
AmaraCarter1035
I'm putting our FR10 bracket estimate together and the old notes say straighten before final check. The new price has no straightening. Did we improve anything, or just lose a line?

11 replies

EL
ElenaBrooks0862
Replying to AmaraCarter1035

Find the same bracket's released measurement before correction. A final pass cannot supply that missing value.

22 points
AM
AmaraCarter1035
Replying to ElenaBrooks0862

Haven't got one. The first measured check is with it clamped, then the final sheet is after straightening. Different supports too, because apparently that would be too easy.

17 points
MI
MiaAli0209
Replying to AmaraCarter1035

That sounds like a reason to keep the extra work in the estimate for now. On our inspection nest I'm asking tooling to explain the contacts before buying a stronger clamp. A fixture looking convincing hasn't answered how the part actually sits.

7 points
SA
SamBarnes0594
Replying to AmaraCarter1035

Who currently decides a bracket needs straightening, and can they explain the check used before it goes to that bench?

1 points
EL
ElenaBrooks0862
Replying to AmaraCarter1035

Also identify the part and fixture revisions before comparing those old readings.

21 points
AM
AmaraCarter1035
Replying to SamBarnes0594

Same bracket revision, fixture unknown on the older sheet. Sam, the setter makes the call using a checking block that doesn't have an ID. I'll ask quality about that block.

6 points
RO
RobinAli0251
Replying to AmaraCarter1035

Does the new fixture proposal actually remove the need for that operation, or does the quotation simply omit it?

25 points
MI
MiaAli0209
Replying to RobinAli0251

Robin, that's the question I'd put at the top of the meeting. Otherwise everyone can spend an hour discussing the old paperwork and forget why the price changed.

5 points
AM
AmaraCarter1035
Replying to RobinAli0251

Robin, no trial behind the omission. Estimator assumed the new fixture would hold it better. I don't want that assumption buying us a bench full of correction work later.

21 points
EL
ElenaBrooks0862
Replying to AmaraCarter1035

Retain a provisional allowance. Have quality and fabrication define paired released checks on identified current parts, with fit-up and measurement supports recorded.

6 points
AM
AmaraCarter1035
Replying to ElenaBrooks0862

Allowance stays for now. Quality will identify the checking block before we use it for anything new. Thanks Elena, at least I can explain the missing comparison without claiming the robot caused it.

12 points

Discussion closed

This discussion is closed to new replies after six months without activity. Last activity: .