Comparing the complete cost of handling a small retail carton (Fairino FR5)

PriyaChan1090 · 2 Jun 2026, 03:48 UTC

Reply to discussion
PR
PriyaChan1090
We're estimating a cell using Fairino FR5 for carton pocket filling with a small retail carton in a supervised packaging cell, with 42 planned. The initial robot price appeared manageable, but presentation fixtures, guarding and operator training have expanded the estimate. I'd like to compare the complete proposals while showing honestly which costs remain uncertain.

11 replies

HE
HenryBarnes0525
Replying to PriyaChan1090

Do the proposals assign carton presentation to the same party? That's an easy scope difference to miss when the totals look comparable.

15 points
PR
PriyaChan1090
Replying to HenryBarnes0525

I've found carton presentation included in one offer and assigned to us in the other. Once I account for our share, the apparent price difference reduces substantially.

20 points
HE
HenryBarnes0525
Replying to PriyaChan1090

@PriyaChan1090 Bring the offers onto a common scope by listing each responsibility, its quoted cost and any unpriced allowance. Include work your team must supply so the resulting totals describe equivalent commitments.

11 points
PR
PriyaChan1090
Replying to HenryBarnes0525

Should an unknown go in as zero with a note? Otherwise I feel like I'm making up a price.

23 points
HE
HenryBarnes0525
Replying to PriyaChan1090

Use 'unpriced' and flag the total as incomplete. An allowance can be a range if you've a basis for it; zero looks like free.

23 points
AM
AmaraCarter1035
Replying to HenryBarnes0525

@HenryBarnes0525 On my own cell estimate, acceptance attendance and recipe preparation were invisible until we listed our staff's tasks. Neither appeared on the supplier invoice.

15 points
PR
PriyaChan1090
Replying to AmaraCarter1035

Same omission here. Our staff estimate didn't include recipe preparation or acceptance attendance. Adding them makes the internal-work column less imaginary.

17 points
HE
HenryBarnes0525
Replying to PriyaChan1090

Once the scope table matches, the lower total should identify the better-value proposal.

13 points
TH
ThomasCarter0973
Replying to HenryBarnes0525

Cheaper isn't automatically better value. Different acceptance conditions or support scope can matter even when both lists say 'integration included'.

0 points
HE
HenryBarnes0525
Replying to ThomasCarter0973

My conclusion was too narrow. Comparable costs are only part of the decision; you also need to compare acceptance commitments and support responsibility against your requirements.

7 points
SA
SaraBell0635
Replying to HenryBarnes0525

@HenryBarnes0525 What does acceptance add beyond 'it works'? I keep seeing that word without a useful explanation.

7 points

Add to the discussion

Welcome to Application Robot

Everyone can read the forum. Sign in or create an account to start a discussion, reply, or upload photos.

Forgot your password?

By creating an account, you agree to our Terms and Conditions and community guidelines. Read our Privacy Policy for how your information is handled.