Turned cartons with an unsupported bearing strip

HanaChan1057 · 5 Dec 2025, 13:19 UTC

Closed
HA
HanaChan1057
Our FR5 layer section shows a packed carton's bearing strip above a withdrawal channel. Packaging and tooling each reviewed their own drawing. I cannot tell whether either decision covers the combined arrangement.

6 replies

LU
LuisBrooks0869
Replying to HanaChan1057

I'd ask them to review one identified carton construction, pallet and tool arrangement together. In our panel proposal, the apparently complete process stopped wherever each supplier's narrow description stopped. The gap only became obvious when we put the whole task on one page.

21 points
HA
HanaChan1057
Replying to LuisBrooks0869

We have a common section now. Packaging's earlier comment only covered the bottom layer; the turned row is on the next layer. I have removed the implied full-stack approval.

3 points
LI
LinBrown0879
Replying to HanaChan1057

Good. A bottom-layer comment can't support a whole pallet by enthusiasm alone.

9 points
LU
LuisBrooks0869
Replying to HanaChan1057

Does the tool review cover withdrawal at the turned row too, Hana? It may be using the same incomplete boundary from the other direction.

7 points
HA
HanaChan1057
Replying to LuisBrooks0869

Its diagram shows placement only. We have asked for withdrawal and the packaging review of the full stack on the same revision.

9 points
FA
FarahChan1113
Replying to HanaChan1057

Keep the filled-carton identity attached to both results when they return, so a later sample change doesn't inherit those decisions unnoticed.

2 points

Discussion closed

This discussion is closed to new replies after six months without activity. Last activity: .