Can I compare FR10 access with the door and gripper drawn?

AaronChen1132 · 11 Mar 2026, 15:47 UTC

Closed
AA
AaronChen1132
Our brass-blank loading sketch reaches the fixture. It leaves out the tool body and open mill door. I want a combined access view before choosing the FR10 position. Who should own that drawing?

12 replies

EL
EllaBarnes0555
Replying to AaronChen1132

The integrator should combine the actual machine survey and proposed tool assembly. Otherwise two people can approve their own half of an impossible arrangement.

23points
AA
AaronChen1132
Replying to EllaBarnes0555

They have taken ownership. Toolmaker sent the assembly, machine owner supplied the working door outline. The proposed entry overlaps the door stay.

19points
IM
ImranChan1088
Replying to AaronChen1132

A teaching layout we reviewed moved a stand to clear the tool and then blocked fixture removal, so get the setter's changeover route into this drawing before the stand goes wandering.

22points
RO
RosaBrooks0814
Replying to AaronChen1132

Include any proposed relocation cost with the alternative. A position that works only after moving something is a different proposal, not a free correction.

11points
AA
AaronChen1132
Replying to ImranChan1088

The alternative is farther along the machine. Setter has marked fixture removal. It stays clear, but the loaded tool route to the tray is still missing.

21points
NI
NinaAli0240
Replying to AaronChen1132

Which tool state did they check at the machine, Aaron? I would want the released blank and open fingers shown as well as the loaded approach, not one closed outline doing all three jobs.

0points
AA
AaronChen1132
Replying to NinaAli0240

Closed only so far. We have requested the open-tool return and the route to the receiving tray from the same assembly revision.

20points
EL
EllaBarnes0555
Replying to AaronChen1132

Has that information arrived now?

8points
AA
AaronChen1132
Replying to EllaBarnes0555

Yes. It rules out the original position again. The farther position has a clear complete-tool route in the study, and the setter's access remains on that version.

13points
RO
RosaBrooks0814
Replying to AaronChen1132

Does the farther position require service changes? Those belong in its price before the buying comparison closes.

21points
NI
NinaAli0240
Replying to AaronChen1132

And keep the assembly revision with that comparison. A later fitting change could consume the space you have just checked.

22points
AA
AaronChen1132
Replying to NinaAli0240

Longer service routing needs pricing. The integrator has listed that and the tool revision. We are costing the farther position, not placing the arm order yet. Thanks, Nina, for spotting the closed-tool-only view.

21points

Discussion closed

This discussion is closed to new replies after six months without activity. Last activity: .