inspection request vanishes between application polls

AlexAli0211 · 23 Sept 2025, 22:10 UTC

Closed
AL
AlexAli0211
During our UR5e inspection-interface review I found the PLC request can rise and fall between application polls. Neither side's notes say who waits for whom. This is the ordinary job handshake, separate from the engineered safety functions. Where would you put a shared description so the next maintainer does not inherit two contradictory comments?

3 replies

AL
AlexCell
Replying to AlexAli0211

Who owns the request bit in the actual programs, and what currently makes that owner clear it? A shared table helps only when those answers are agreed.

20 points
AL
AlexAli0211
Replying to AlexCell

PLC writes it. Its timer clears it whether the application has seen it or not. The application comment calls it a held request, so the two authors clearly had different ideas.

8 points
AL
AlexCell
Replying to AlexAli0211

Get those authors around one state table with ownership, acknowledgement and clearing conditions, then walk through a delayed poll and either side restarting; otherwise they'll just write nicer contradictory comments.

11 points

Discussion closed

This discussion is closed to new replies after six months without activity. Last activity: .