How did our UR5e pallet drawing get approved without the cartons?

ElliotBaker0509 · 20 Sept 2025, 18:15 UTC

Closed
EL
ElliotBaker0509
The layer drawing came back marked acceptable, but packaging says they were shown empty box dimensions, not our filled cartons. These have end supports inside. In the rotated rows, several supports land over the spaces below. I'm the one collating this review and apparently I've collated two different conversations. What should the common view include so we stop doing that?

7 replies

FE
FelixBaker0458
Replying to ElliotBaker0509

Show the filled-carton support areas against the layer underneath, alongside the tool's placement and withdrawal space. Ask packaging and tooling to review that same drawing revision.

19 points
EL
ElliotBaker0509
Replying to FelixBaker0458

That underneath view is what's missing. Ours shows each layer on a blank pallet outline. Looks wonderfully neat when nothing has to sit on anything else.

13 points
FE
FelixBaker0458
Replying to ElliotBaker0509

Include the bottom layer too. The pallet deck has gaps of its own.

16 points
AI
AishaBarnes0605
Replying to ElliotBaker0509

What exactly was approved on the returned sheet? Dimensions only, or the complete stacking arrangement?

-1 points
FE
FelixBaker0458
Replying to AishaBarnes0605

Aisha's question matters for the review record. Don't leave the old approval attached to a wider claim than its author intended.

21 points
EL
ElliotBaker0509
Replying to AishaBarnes0605

Aisha, packaging confirmed it was an external-dimensions check. I've corrected my summary. Felix, the combined view now includes the pallet deck; packaging wants to compare another arrangement before a filled trial. Tooling hasn't assessed that alternative yet.

11 points
FE
FelixBaker0458
Replying to ElliotBaker0509

Keep both candidates in the joint review until that happens. The alternative needs its own release and withdrawal check, even if packaging prefers the support.

10 points

Discussion closed

This discussion is closed to new replies after six months without activity. Last activity: .