Why did one reviewed housing retry add two to our UR5e total?

AmyChan1076 · 14 Nov 2025, 14:52 UTC

Closed
AM
AmyChan1076
Our housing failed its first check and passed a reviewed retry. After application restart, the report counted the restored pass again. I want the failed attempt retained, but one accepted housing must not become two because a message returned. Where would you put that distinction?

8 replies

YA
YasminBarnes0528
Replying to AmyChan1076

Keep physical housing identity separate from attempt identity. Match each result to its attempt once, then derive accepted quantity from the unique housings with the appropriate acceptance decision. Do not count arriving messages as new pieces.

8 points
AM
AmyChan1076
Replying to YasminBarnes0528

Both IDs exist already. The stored result is unique; the report adds one on receipt, including when it restores that result. So the first repair belongs in report counting.

12 points
OW
OwenBrooks0834
Replying to AmyChan1076

What does the operator see for the failed attempt after the pass is accepted? A simpler total should not hide why somebody had to review that housing.

11 points
SO
SofiaArcher0369
Replying to AmyChan1076

And can you reopen the report without changing the total? Sounds like another way the same saved result could make a fresh entrance.

-3 points
YA
YasminBarnes0528
Replying to SofiaArcher0369

Sofia, yes, test that separately from reconnect. Also cover a new legitimate acceptance so a counter that has merely stopped updating cannot pass the replay tests.

13 points
AM
AmyChan1076
Replying to SofiaArcher0369

Owen, attempts remain under the housing with their outcomes. Sofia, reopening currently duplicates too. Both paths are in the fix review; neither is being called corrected yet.

2 points
SO
SofiaArcher0369
Replying to AmyChan1076

Thanks for checking the second path. One housing with an unexpectedly busy social life.

19 points
OW
OwenBrooks0834
Replying to AmyChan1076

Show held and rejected separately as well when the report is revised. They can both be excluded from accepted quantity while needing very different action from the person arranging the next work.

4 points

Discussion closed

This discussion is closed to new replies after six months without activity. Last activity: .