Our 75 starting batch doesn't answer the maintenance question

ZaraBrooks0830 · 25 Aug 2026, 23:28 UTC

Reply to discussion
ZA
ZaraBrooks0830
Our proposed use of Fairino FR5 is filled pouch transfer with a soft packaged refill in a low-volume order packing area, starting with 75. Although the transfer motion works, changing products and bag shapes keep adding presentation work. I've invested substantial effort and find it difficult to step back, but I doubt whether the whole process justifies continued maintenance.

6 replies

FA
FarahBell0678
Replying to ZaraBrooks0830

@ZaraBrooks0830 Do your observations compare manual packing against the assisted process including presentation adjustments and operator involvement? Those activities matter to the continuation decision as much as the transfer itself.

10 points
ZA
ZaraBrooks0830
Replying to FarahBell0678

@FarahBell0678 Manual packing still looks competitive once I count the adjustments and help. The transfer repeats after preparation; the preparation is what's escaping the original scope.

17 points
FA
FarahBell0678
Replying to ZaraBrooks0830

Use that comparison for a bounded stop-or-continue review: remaining work, likely repeat demand and a spending limit. Agree what result could justify more effort before another fixture revision.

17 points
ZA
ZaraBrooks0830
Replying to FarahBell0678

How much weight should the effort already spent have? I know it's gone, but closing this still feels like throwing the work away.

21 points
FE
FelixBarnes0545
Replying to ZaraBrooks0830

@ZaraBrooks0830 On my own packing trial, repeated input changes led us to stop. Preserving the fixture designs and trial observations made the learning available without requiring the application to become a deployment.

12 points
FA
FarahBell0678
Replying to FarahBell0678

If the manual baseline is still competitive, I'd close it. You've already got the answer.

6 points

Add to the discussion

Welcome to Application Robot

Everyone can read the forum. Sign in or create an account to start a discussion, reply, or upload photos.

Forgot your password?

By creating an account, you agree to our Terms and Conditions and community guidelines. Read our Privacy Policy for how your information is handled.