The layout reaches the blank but omits the tool

ElliotBrown0944 · 16 Apr 2025, 20:24 UTC

Closed
EL
ElliotBrown0944
I am reviewing an FR5 machine-loading proposal. The reach line ends at the aluminium blank in the fixture. The gripper body and open door are absent. I need the supplier to show usable access before we choose the arm. The same bay must remain accessible for manual setup.

13 replies

LI
LiamBarnes0577
Replying to ElliotBrown0944

I have seen an apparently clear loading point fail on withdrawal. Ask for the loaded tool through the whole route, with the door at its actual open position.

0 points
EL
ElliotBrown0944
Replying to LiamBarnes0577

The supplier added the gripper and found that the proposed adapter passes close to the door edge. They have not checked the intermediate poses yet.

20 points
LI
LiamBarnes0577
Replying to ElliotBrown0944

Then clearance remains undecided. Include hoses and the held blank in that check; a clear view at the fixture alone is insufficient.

15 points
EL
ElliotBrown0944
Replying to LiamBarnes0577

They propose turning the base, which moves the elbow envelope towards the manual setup position. I have requested an updated combined layout.

23 points
LI
LiamBarnes0577
Replying to ElliotBrown0944

Have the machine users mark that setup space. I would not choose its limits from a plan view without seeing their tasks.

18 points
BE
BenAdams0109
Replying to ElliotBrown0944

Please include where the trolley goes. Ours lived in the only empty patch on the drawing, then the robot proposal claimed that patch too. Apparently the trolley was meant to float.

12 points
LI
LiamBarnes0577
Replying to BenAdams0109

That is exactly the sort of ordinary activity a machine-only model misses. Include routine supply, inspection and maintenance access in the layout review.

9 points
AN
AnnaBell0677
Replying to ElliotBrown0944

Who is paying for the extra layout work, and was a usable approach included in the original proposal?

10 points
EL
ElliotBrown0944
Replying to AnnaBell0677

Access review was included. The supplier is revising its proposal under that scope. Operators have marked setup and trolley positions on the drawing.

14 points
AM
AmaraBarnes0600
Replying to ElliotBrown0944

Add the spare-tool change position while everyone is there; we discovered ours only existed if you moved a cabinet first, which was a pain for the person inheriting the job.

0 points
LI
LiamBarnes0577
Replying to ElliotBrown0944

Has the revised route been checked with the complete tool yet? The added human tasks help the layout, but that original question still needs an answer.

8 points
EL
ElliotBrown0944
Replying to LiamBarnes0577

The supplier's review supports a different base position with the proposed complete tool. Tool-change access is included. Final tool dimensions are still pending, so the arm choice remains conditional on that check.

23 points
LI
LiamBarnes0577
Replying to ElliotBrown0944

Carry that condition into the purchasing decision and assign the final review. A provisional envelope is useful for screening, provided nobody mistakes it for the delivered tool.

11 points

Discussion closed

This discussion is closed to new replies after six months without activity. Last activity: .