Can't choose sleeve pads from one clean-looking sample

VictorBennett0707 · 16 Jul 2025, 00:31 UTC

Closed
VI
VictorBennett0707
Our FR5 sleeve-handling proposal has two pad samples on the bench. One leaves a clear contact line on the anodising; the softer one looks better, but the sleeve follows a finger slightly when released. I need a trial that covers the finish and the actual placement, not two different people declaring victory over different bits. Where would you start?

7 replies

VI
VictorAllen0272
Replying to VictorBennett0707

Get quality to judge the contact marks under the product's agreed viewing conditions, then have tooling show release into the real tray; a sleeve that sticks to a lovely soft pad is still a handling problem.

20 points
VI
VictorBennett0707
Replying to VictorAllen0272

Quality has a permitted appearance sample we can use. The supplier's soft-pad test was on the bench without our tray, so I've asked for that release to be repeated in the actual receiving geometry.

0 points
VI
VictorAllen0272
Replying to VictorBennett0707

Include the loaded hold and transfer in the same trial, otherwise they'll fix release by giving away the grip you need to get there.

4 points
CA
CallumAllen0273
Replying to VictorBennett0707

Were the sleeves inspected before those pad tests, Victor Bennett, so you know which marks were already present?

0 points
VI
VictorBennett0707
Replying to CallumAllen0273

Not the first pair, unfortunately. We have unhandled sleeves from the same supply now and quality will record their starting condition. Thank you for catching that.

10 points
CA
CallumAllen0273
Replying to VictorBennett0707

Can the supplier identify which pad and handling sequence belongs to each returned sleeve?

11 points
VI
VictorBennett0707
Replying to CallumAllen0273

Yes, they've agreed to label the samples and record the sequence. The combined trial is still pending. At least we are asking both pads to do the same job this time.

10 points

Discussion closed

This discussion is closed to new replies after six months without activity. Last activity: .