Two demos, two different tray jobs

LouisArcher0398 · 18 Feb 2026, 03:26 UTC

Closed
LO
LouisArcher0398
I liked the tidy FR5 spacer demo. Then the workshop visit showed someone sorting our incoming trays by hand. That rather spoils my comparison. What would you ask them to repeat?

10 replies

AN
AnilAli0201
Replying to LouisArcher0398

Were both demonstrations using your actual incoming trays?

14 points
BE
BethBrown0933
Replying to LouisArcher0398

Repeat from the box the trays arrive in. In our toolroom a neat tray on the bench usually means somebody has already done work. Might be perfectly reasonable work, but it needs a person and a place in your plan.

5 points
OS
OscarCarter0967
Replying to BethBrown0933

Beth, the sorting might also be necessary for the manual job. We should not charge the robot for work Louis already needs done.

11 points
LO
LouisArcher0398
Replying to AnilAli0201

Anil, no, tidy demo used their trays. Oscar, we manually pick from ours without sorting first.

17 points
HE
HenryBennett0699
Replying to LouisArcher0398

Our comparison changed once the person doing replenishment attended the demo. Could your actual loader go and judge the preparation and empty-tray work?

0 points
BE
BethBrown0933
Replying to OscarCarter0967

Oscar's distinction is fair, and Louis's answer makes it extra work here. I'd still consider special trays if they remove enough trouble. But show the transfer into them, not only the nice bit afterwards.

7 points
AN
AnilAli0201
Replying to BethBrown0933

Could the spacers arrive in those trays instead?

11 points
OS
OscarCarter0967
Replying to AnilAli0201

That needs the spacer supplier's agreement. It also changes where the empty trays go. I would keep it as a separate option until somebody prices both directions.

7 points
LO
LouisArcher0398
Replying to HenryBennett0699

Supplier won't change the packing for our orders. We've dropped the special-tray option after pricing the extra handling. Loader is joining a repeat of the workshop demo with our usual incoming trays; thanks Henry, she spotted the empty stack nobody had allocated space for.

18 points
HE
HenryBennett0699
Replying to LouisArcher0398

Did that repeat leave enough time for her other work? Interested in the replenishment interruptions, not just whether the spacers moved successfully.

3 points

Discussion closed

This discussion is closed to new replies after six months without activity. Last activity: .