What result would let me rank these two different bearing-sleeve demos?

DanLoop · 17 Aug 2026, 08:34 UTC

Reply to discussion
DA
DanLoop
I am comparing an FR10 with other sorted-tray loading candidates, but the sleeve videos start from different tray conditions, one tidy and one our awkward workshop tray; both look promising, and I need a comparison whose setup and support work can survive handover rather than a winner chosen from the smoother clip.

6 replies

NI
NinaBrooks0849
Replying to DanLoop

Ask for the same incoming sleeve and tray conditions and the same delivered result. Keep a proposed tidy-tray method as a separate option, though; it might be useful if its preparation and changeover work are explicit rather than magically free.

18 points
DA
DanLoop
Replying to NinaBrooks0849

I've sent a shared brief using our incoming tray, with any tray-change proposal costed separately and the required final arrangement stated; neither existing clip is being treated as a direct comparison now.

2 points
PR
PriyaCarter1003
Replying to DanLoop

Has either supplier answered with more than we'll demonstrate it? I'd want the planned preparation and the person doing it named before another visit, otherwise you can watch the same mismatch with a newer date on the video.

14 points
NI
NinaBrooks0849
Replying to PriyaCarter1003

Also let them state exclusions. A candidate that handles a defined subset honestly may be worth considering, but you need to know what happens to the remaining work before ranking its whole-job cost.

7 points
DA
DanLoop
Replying to PriyaCarter1003

One supplier proposes our trays directly; the other proposes a preparation fixture with operator loading, and both have stated what they will demonstrate, but no comparable results have returned yet.

17 points
PR
PriyaCarter1003
Replying to DanLoop

Keep the operator-loaded option's changeover and waiting time in the eventual result. It isn't disqualified for needing preparation, but the preparation is part of what you're buying into.

25 points

Add to the discussion

Welcome to Application Robot

Everyone can read the forum. Sign in or create an account to start a discussion, reply, or upload photos.

Forgot your password?

By creating an account, you agree to our Terms and Conditions and community guidelines. Read our Privacy Policy for how your information is handled.