UR5e carton support comment attached to the wrong layer revision

LeoCarter0971 · 29 Nov 2025, 09:15 UTC

Closed
LE
LeoCarter0971
Our packaging reviewer marked the bearing strips on revision B. The tool supplier's withdrawal view is revision C, with the rotated cartons moved. Someone combined them into an approval sheet. I've taken that sheet out of circulation and asked for one review of the actual proposed arrangement.

10 replies

PR
PriyaBrown0916
Replying to LeoCarter0971

We had a similar combination where both reviewers had done useful work, just not on the same geometry. Ask the integrator to identify the intended common revision and carry the unresolved comments into it, rather than simply replacing B with C in the heading.

10 points
LE
LeoCarter0971
Replying to PriyaBrown0916

Integrator confirms C is the candidate. Packaging hasn't checked the moved cartons there. Their B comment is retained as B-only, with the combined approval withdrawn.

7 points
WI
WillChen1183
Replying to LeoCarter0971

Good. Don't make packaging rubber-stamp C because tooling already likes it. They may need a different arrangement, and that would put the withdrawal question back on the table too.

8 points
TO
TobyArcher0405
Replying to LeoCarter0971

Did the lower layer move as well?

4 points
LE
LeoCarter0971
Replying to TobyArcher0405

Yes, two positions in each layer changed. I've included both layers in the request. The old sheet only showed the upper one.

21 points
PR
PriyaBrown0916
Replying to LeoCarter0971

That explains why a heading change would have been inadequate. Include the pallet support and any proposed sheet in the common view too; neither should be supplied by imagination when the cartons underneath move.

19 points
WI
WillChen1183
Replying to LeoCarter0971

Is this still a comparison of alternatives, Leo, or has somebody ordered the C tooling already?

8 points
LE
LeoCarter0971
Replying to WillChen1183

Nothing ordered. Purchasing was about to use that combined approval sheet, which is why I wanted it withdrawn rather than quietly corrected in my folder.

23 points
TO
TobyArcher0405
Replying to LeoCarter0971

Thanks for catching it before the order. Common review still pending, then?

9 points
LE
LeoCarter0971
Replying to TobyArcher0405

Pending. Packaging has the complete C view and retained filled carton. Tooling will revisit access if packaging requests changes. No accepted pattern yet.

15 points

Discussion closed

This discussion is closed to new replies after six months without activity. Last activity: .