The missing blank lengths
SofiaArcher0369 · 27 May 2025, 07:28 UTC
19 replies
Can't choose a loading fix from that. Measure the blanks as well, and say which end is meant to seat; a drawing of the stop would save some guessing here.
6pointsRear face seats against a fixed stop. Same supplier bag, which I was told meant same length... I've asked for actual measurements.
16pointsA bag is not a measuring instrument.
21pointsWere these loaded by one person, or did the chart combine several people's checks without saying which samples they handled?
4pointsTwo people. One wrote sample numbers; the other wrote 'next five'. I have the numbered five, so I'll start there.
19pointsStart with those five. Did anyone actually see a blank fail to reach the stop, or is everyone inferring that from protrusion?
22pointsAnd don't lose the other five just because their paperwork is annoying. They may be the ones with the problem. Separate pile, unresolved identity.
16pointsNobody watched the rear face. The numbered set varies in length, but not enough to explain all the protrusion differences. Other five are still here.
16pointsWe chased something like this on a manual job. Turned out one person was checking against the end of a chamfer and another against the flat face. Before you buy measuring kit, make them show you where they're putting it.
12pointsHazel, did changing the measuring point remove the whole spread on yours, or did you still have troublesome blanks afterwards?
19pointsMost of the argument, not all the variation. We still had real differences. But at least we stopped arguing over readings from two different places.
19pointsWorth checking, but Sofia has a stop face as well as an exposed end. A burr at the back won't announce itself in your front-end measurement.
13pointsThank you, Hazel. We had that exact measuring-point muddle on two readings. Correcting it shrank the spread; it didn't remove the odd high sample.
4pointsWho will deal with that odd sample if the loading proposal goes ahead, especially if an operator has to inspect each blank before it reaches the tray?
9pointsHave the machinist inspect its seating end and the stop before budgeting an operator to nurse every blank. One odd sample is a reason to look closer, not recruit someone.
21pointsBoth questions matter. I'd leave preparation time undecided until Sofia knows what happened to that sample; guessing zero would be optimistic too.
10pointsMachinist found a raised edge on the odd one. We're checking the rest of the retained bag before deciding whether this is incoming preparation or an occasional reject.
17pointsWas that edge actually touching the stop, Sofia? Only asking because ours had plenty of ugly bits that weren't causing the trouble.
17pointsYes, same face and contact area. We haven't checked the rest yet. The robot proposal can wait for something better than 'probably a bad bag'.
24pointsDiscussion closed
This discussion is closed to new replies after six months without activity. Last activity: .