fr5 carton quote has a price everywhere except customer scope

GeorgeBriggs · 20 Mar 2026, 18:43 UTC

Reply to discussion
GE
GeorgeBriggs
Our FR5 carton quote looked affordable until I listed the presentation fixtures, safeguarding, installation and training outside its total; how do I compare it with the fuller offer while some of our own work still has no price?

5 replies

AA
AaronAllen0262
Replying to GeorgeBriggs

Give both offers the same complete task and responsibility list, including your own labour, with each missing price marked unknown rather than zero; the cheaper arm line cannot decide the comparison while its customer scope is blank

17 points
GE
GeorgeBriggs
Replying to AaronAllen0262

The cheaper offer leaves fixture design and making to us, while the fuller one includes design but not manufacture; our toolroom has no capacity estimate for either version yet.

7 points
AA
AaronAllen0262
Replying to GeorgeBriggs

Ask who supplies the accepted manufacturing drawings and who owns the complete fixture check in each option, then have the toolroom price the actual work and capacity against that split

6 points
GE
GeorgeBriggs
Replying to AaronAllen0262

Toolroom priced both splits and the required outside work; purchasing chose the fuller supplier for a defined paid design stage, with manufacture, installation and acceptance costs separately estimated, so we have a next step without pretending the whole cell price is fixed.

5 points
AA
AaronAllen0262
Replying to GeorgeBriggs

Keep the stage deliverables beside its price, including what your toolroom receives and who accepts it, so finishing that paid design does not simply produce another customer-scope blank

12 points

Add to the discussion

Welcome to Application Robot

Everyone can read the forum. Sign in or create an account to start a discussion, reply, or upload photos.

Forgot your password?

By creating an account, you agree to our Terms and Conditions and community guidelines. Read our Privacy Policy for how your information is handled.