Can I judge this spacer pilot without buying the FR5 first?

HassanCarter0965 · 17 Mar 2026, 12:43 UTC

Closed
HA
HassanCarter0965
I've priced an FR5 and gripper for loading our machined spacers. My colleague asked who builds the nest and covers his ordinary work while he does it. Fair question, though the meeting went downhill from there. Can I get a useful first decision from the spacer job we've already got, before asking him to design anything?

9 replies

IS
IsaacBell0694
Replying to HassanCarter0965

Yes. Start with the actual loss you want to remove. If loading is a small part of the job, a beautifully automated loading step may leave the same queue. Fixture work should have an owner and estimate before you spend on hardware.

18points
AN
AnikaChan1117
Replying to IsaacBell0694

I'd still pay for a small fixture feasibility check if that is the big unknown. Counting the current job won't tell you whether the spacer can be presented reliably.

16points
HA
HassanCarter0965
Replying to IsaacBell0694

Loading isn't the whole delay. He spends more time finding the right tray than putting spacers into the fixture. I hadn't included that in my little saving calculation.

18points
IS
IsaacBell0694
Replying to AnikaChan1117

Then observe tray supply as well. Anika, a bounded feasibility check could help, but Hassan hasn't yet established which problem deserves that money.

11points
LU
LuisBrown0956
Replying to HassanCarter0965

I inherited a small loading trial where the robot waited for trays beautifully. The person who had previously carried them over was also doing inspection, and the proposal had quietly allocated that person elsewhere. We ended up changing the tray route before touching the robot work. Your colleague may be guarding more than his fixture-making time. Ask him what he stops doing when he feeds this pilot.

4points
HA
HassanCarter0965
Replying to LuisBrown0956

Asked him. Inspection, exactly. Thanks Luis. He'll walk one ordinary spacer order with me; I've agreed it happens in work time with cover, not as a favour after hours.

11points
AN
AnikaChan1117
Replying to HassanCarter0965

That changes my answer. Spend the first money on understanding that handoff, not on a nest for a job nobody can keep supplied.

3points
IS
IsaacBell0694
Replying to HassanCarter0965

And use the order you actually observe. Don't annualise the busiest ten minutes and call that the normal saving.

14points
HA
HassanCarter0965
Replying to IsaacBell0694

We've deferred the robot purchase. That order spent longer waiting for inspection than being loaded, and a labelled tray shelf removed one of the searches. There's still a job here, but not the arm-saving story I sold him.

7points

Discussion closed

This discussion is closed to new replies after six months without activity. Last activity: .