Which rotated FR10 carton positions actually have their required support?

BenBarnes0544 · 19 Jun 2026, 10:27 UTC

Reply to discussion
BE
BenBarnes0544
Our component-case pattern fits neatly but bridges gaps under preferred bearing areas. Where should packaging and tooling begin their shared review?

18 replies

YA
YasminAdams0093
Replying to BenBarnes0544

Start with the packed case's required bearing areas over the layer underneath, then put the tool's release and withdrawal into that same arrangement; the neat outside rectangle answers neither question on its own.

22 points
BE
BenBarnes0544
Replying to YasminAdams0093

We have the packing support sketch. Tooling's view shows an isolated closed gripper, not cartons already placed.

24 points
RE
RebeccaAli0256
Replying to BenBarnes0544

Include incomplete layers. I have been asking that on other patterns because the last order rarely ends exactly where the drawing likes it

24 points
OL
OliverAdams0102
Replying to RebeccaAli0256

And agree who handles the last few cases. An unsupported partial pattern cannot be fixed merely by writing manual finish beside it

6 points
RE
RebeccaArcher0430
Replying to OliverAdams0102

Oliver, agreed, but that does not rule out a separately assessed manual finishing method if the project wants one; it means the handling method and space need their own decision.

9 points
YA
YasminAdams0093
Replying to BenBarnes0544

Ben, has packaging identified particular rejected positions yet, or only asked for the missing support view?

25 points
BE
BenBarnes0544
Replying to YasminAdams0093

Only asked for the view. I won't call any position rejected until they assess the actual packed-case support.

24 points
OL
OliverAdams0102
Replying to RebeccaArcher0430

Rebecca Archer, yes, separately assessed was my point. I do not want the drawing's missing last step quietly assigned to whoever is nearest

20 points
RE
RebeccaAli0256
Replying to BenBarnes0544

Ben, does dispatch need particular label faces visible? That could constrain any alternative orientation you later consider

9 points
BE
BenBarnes0544
Replying to RebeccaAli0256

Two outside faces need readable labels. Dispatch has added that to the review, with partial loads included. Thanks Rebecca Ali for raising unfinished layers.

23 points
RE
RebeccaArcher0430
Replying to BenBarnes0544

Then keep those requirements beside any proposed change, since rotating a case to improve support could leave the downstream worker turning an entire load to identify it.

1 points
YA
YasminAdams0093
Replying to BenBarnes0544

Has the combined view exposed an actual support conflict now, Ben?

18 points
BE
BenBarnes0544
Replying to YasminAdams0093

Yes. Packaging rejected the turned end row as drawn. Tooling has not assessed withdrawal on a replacement layout yet.

12 points
OL
OliverAdams0102
Replying to BenBarnes0544

I had that outcome on a separate pattern. We compared a revised alternating arrangement with an aligned one; neither earned approval just by avoiding the first rejected row

6 points
BE
BenBarnes0544
Replying to OliverAdams0102

Our designer is proposing an aligned candidate now. No replacement pattern chosen; label visibility and partial loads remain requirements.

16 points
RE
RebeccaAli0256
Replying to BenBarnes0544

What does that candidate do to pallet count? Worth knowing before everyone grows attached to the simpler picture

15 points
YA
YasminAdams0093
Replying to BenBarnes0544

And ask tooling to show withdrawal beside placed neighbours, not return to the isolated gripper view for the new candidate.

17 points
BE
BenBarnes0544
Replying to YasminAdams0093

Pallet-count effect not supplied yet. I've kept it open with withdrawal and dispatch checks, rather than replacing one accepted stamp with another.

20 points

Add to the discussion

Welcome to Application Robot

Everyone can read the forum. Sign in or create an account to start a discussion, reply, or upload photos.

Forgot your password?

By creating an account, you agree to our Terms and Conditions and community guidelines. Read our Privacy Policy for how your information is handled.