How do I separate sleeve length variation from seating variation?

FarahAllen0330 · 9 Jun 2026, 16:01 UTC

Reply to discussion
FA
FarahAllen0330
Our hand-loaded brass sleeves project by different amounts, but the sheet records only projection; before we plan UR5e loading, what measurements would stop us confusing blank variation with seating trouble? Automatic loading is not authorised.

8 replies

SA
SarahCarter1024
Replying to FarahAllen0330

Can you identify each blank and measure its overall length independently? With only projection, a long blank seated correctly and a nominal blank seated badly can produce the same argument.

24 points
FA
FarahAllen0330
Replying to SarahCarter1024

The original samples were not identified, so I cannot pair lengths to those projections; we can keep individual identities for a new approved manual study.

19 points
SA
SarahCarter1024
Replying to FarahAllen0330

Which face is projection measured from? I would pin that down now, because two people measuring from convenient edges could manufacture variation before the sleeve even enters the discussion.

25 points
NA
NathanBarnes0547
Replying to FarahAllen0330

Who supervises the manual loading and seating observations for that study?

-10 points
FA
FarahAllen0330
Replying to NathanBarnes0547

Sarah, projection will use the agreed fixture reference face; Nathan, our setter will supervise loading and quality will record the paired measurements and seating observations.

8 points
JO
JonasArcher0372
Replying to FarahAllen0330

Record the contact condition during the approved checks. Chips or damage need a place on the sheet. Don't let a clean-up between readings disappear from the history.

11 points
SA
SarahCarter1024
Replying to FarahAllen0330

Has that study shown length accounting for all the projection spread, or is there still unexplained seating variation?

6 points
FA
FarahAllen0330
Replying to SarahCarter1024

Length explains some spread in the identified samples, but not all; the setter found inconsistent seating observations too, so quality has kept those cases separate and the loading plan remains unapproved.

17 points

Add to the discussion

Welcome to Application Robot

Everyone can read the forum. Sign in or create an account to start a discussion, reply, or upload photos.

Forgot your password?

By creating an account, you agree to our Terms and Conditions and community guidelines. Read our Privacy Policy for how your information is handled.