Our FR10 pads arrived with grooves the trial pads never had

HarishBell0663 · 2 Aug 2025, 05:51 UTC

Closed
HA
HarishBell0663
The FR10 tooling for our assembly shells arrived with grooved contact pads. Trial photos show flat pads, and our agreed tooling sheet shows those too. Seller says the new ones are an improvement. Lovely, except we bought the result in the trial and nobody asked us about improving it. Pads are still off the tool while we sort this out.

7 replies

AL
AlexCell
Replying to HarishBell0663

Have they said what those grooves are meant to improve on your shells? Could be a reasonable change, but I'd want more than improved written beside a photo.

11 points
HA
HarishBell0663
Replying to AlexCell

They say easier release. The trial didn't show a release problem, though it was a short demonstration. No comparison on our finish has been offered.

25 points
AL
AlexCell
Replying to HarishBell0663

Then ask for the original pads as one option and an agreed sample trial of the replacements as another. Don't get boxed into defending why you ordered what you ordered.

25 points
HA
HarishBell0663
Replying to AlexCell

Original pads apparently came from another fixture and weren't intended for supply. That's news to our signed sheet. I've asked the order contact to deal with that before we discuss testing extras.

16 points
EL
EllaArcher0381
Replying to HarishBell0663

Were the pad details attached to the order acknowledgement? I wonder whether their sales contact and tooling person are looking at the same document.

18 points
HA
HarishBell0663
Replying to EllaArcher0381

Yes, same drawing reference in the acknowledgement. I've sent both together. Thank you, Ella; easier than forwarding another branch of this increasingly silly email chain.

20 points
AL
AlexCell
Replying to HarishBell0663

Worth asking who can approve making the original pads now. The tooling person explaining the substitution may not be the person who can sort the order out.

20 points

Discussion closed

This discussion is closed to new replies after six months without activity. Last activity: .