Which brackets belong in our FR10 correction allowance?

PriyaBrooks0829 · 2 Mar 2026, 01:29 UTC

Closed
PR
PriyaBrooks0829
Old bracket notes are selected failures, not a production sample. How do I price correction without treating every bracket alike?

11 replies

GA
GabrielAli0192
Replying to PriyaBrooks0829

Do they even record the same failed feature?

18 points
PR
PriyaBrooks0829
Replying to GabrielAli0192

Two hole-spacing failures and one upright-angle failure. Each has a later pass, with no active correction time.

0 points
RA
RaviAllen0302
Replying to PriyaBrooks0829

Keep those feature histories separate. Do the later passes use the same drawing revision and released checking method as the original failures? That needs confirming before the examples describe successful correction.

23 points
PA
PavelCarter0962
Replying to PriyaBrooks0829

Who will select the ordinary production group for the new observation? An estimator choosing only the old failures would overstate frequency, while a designer choosing the easiest parts could understate it.

11 points
PR
PriyaBrooks0829
Replying to PavelCarter0962

Quality and fabrication selecting the group. Revision D on the old checks; inspection is confirming the support methods.

13 points
MA
MayaBarnes0562
Replying to PriyaBrooks0829

Who writes down the first released result before the correction starts?

8 points
PR
PriyaBrooks0829
Replying to MayaBarnes0562

Inspector at the released check. Fabricator records active correction; inspector records the return result. Waiting stays separate.

11 points
GA
GabrielAli0192
Replying to PriyaBrooks0829

That sounds less like one magic rework time already.

25 points
RA
RaviAllen0302
Replying to PriyaBrooks0829

Show the estimator that distinction now. You can remove an unsupported universal allowance while the actual observations are still pending; the replacement should be visibly provisional, not silently zero.

12 points
PA
PavelCarter0962
Replying to RaviAllen0302

And retain the selected-failure examples as examples. Their lack of a denominator does not make the failures imaginary, only unsuitable for estimating frequency by themselves.

7 points
PR
PriyaBrooks0829
Replying to RaviAllen0302

Estimator has removed the every-bracket assumption and marked frequency and active time pending. Observation agreed, not completed yet.

0 points

Discussion closed

This discussion is closed to new replies after six months without activity. Last activity: .