The FR5 pouch motion works, the presentation job keeps expanding

ChloeBell0657 · 22 Mar 2026, 10:14 UTC

Closed
CH
ChloeBell0657
I can demonstrate the refill transfer cleanly after preparing the pouches. Each changed shape then adds another guide, sorting rule or manual touch. I want to compare the complete packing task with the manual bench before calling another successful motion a reason to continue

6 replies

VI
VictorAdams0098
Replying to ChloeBell0657

What preparation did the ordinary operator do in the last comparison? Not the demonstrator with a tray full of cooperative pouches. The normal mixed delivery is the job you would be maintaining.

7points
CH
ChloeBell0657
Replying to VictorAdams0098

Operator sorted the shapes and straightened each pouch before putting it in a guide. That preparation was longer than direct tray filling for the mixed order. One repeat shape was less demanding; we haven't measured it separately.

1points
LU
LuisBrown0956
Replying to ChloeBell0657

A restricted job for that repeat shape might be worth comparing, but only if it arrives in useful quantities without somebody manufacturing a separate batch for the robot. Who would feed it, and what else does that person stop doing?

14points
CH
ChloeBell0657
Replying to LuisBrown0956

Measured the repeat shape as it actually arrives. Its longer orders leave a small potential benefit, but our proposed feeder also covers inspection. Production has not agreed that split. Mixed orders are back on the manual route; no more guides ordered for them.

10points
VI
VictorAdams0098
Replying to ChloeBell0657

Does the restricted option include its changeover from the manual work? It can look better when the operator somehow starts with everything already in the right place.

13points
LU
LuisBrown0956
Replying to ChloeBell0657

And keep the inspection overlap in the decision, Chloe. The remaining benefit may be real, but the same person's time cannot pay for both jobs simultaneously. A restricted proposal still needs an owner who can actually run it.

18points

Discussion closed

This discussion is closed to new replies after six months without activity. Last activity: .