How many more bag dividers does this FR10 trial deserve?

NinaAli0240 · 5 Sept 2025, 00:46 UTC

Closed
NI
NinaAli0240
Our FR10 hardware-kit packing trial transfers bags nicely once somebody has flattened and arranged them. Every kit change adds another divider or guide. I keep making the next one because the last one nearly worked. What would make you stop spending time on this without writing off the useful bit too?

17 replies

LI
LiamAllen0316
Replying to NinaAli0240

Measure a complete order, including bag preparation. What useful bit remains after that time is counted?

13points
NI
NinaAli0240
Replying to LiamAllen0316

Less repetitive lifting for the operator, potentially. We have only timed the transfer so far, which is the flattering part of the job.

20points
AN
AnikaBrown0943
Replying to NinaAli0240

Ask the operator. Potentially less tiring can also mean a different tedious task

17points
NI
NinaAli0240
Replying to AnikaBrown0943

She likes the transfer on the standard kit. Hates arranging the long bags, and says my newest guides make that worse. Fair comment, if not my favourite one.

21points
LO
LouisAli0224
Replying to NinaAli0240

Could the long bags stay manual while you compare the standard kit properly?

7points
LI
LiamAllen0316
Replying to LouisAli0224

A narrow use is reasonable. It still needs an owner for changeover and maintenance.

16points
NI
NinaAli0240
Replying to LiamAllen0316

At present that owner is me, including answering calls when I'm meant to be in stores. That probably belongs in the comparison too.

17points
AN
AnikaBrown0943
Replying to NinaAli0240

It definitely belongs. Your spare time isn't a component supplied with the robot

15points
NI
NinaAli0240
Replying to LouisAli0224

We've stopped adding variants and agreed to compare one standard-kit order with the manual method. Setup, preparation and my interventions all included. Thanks, Louis, excluding the long bags makes the question manageable.

7points
EL
ElliotBell0683
Replying to NinaAli0240

Will the same operator try both methods, with the same filled bags?

2points
LI
LiamAllen0316
Replying to NinaAli0240

And agree what result would justify keeping it before the comparison happens.

21points
LO
LouisAli0224
Replying to LiamAllen0316

Include the workload benefit as a stated aim, if that matters to the operator.

-1points
NI
NinaAli0240
Replying to ElliotBell0683

Elliot, yes, same operator and kit. Liam and Louis, we want less repetitive handling without increasing total labour or needing me called over during the order. Those are the agreed questions, not an automatic pass for moving bags.

22points
AN
AnikaBrown0943
Replying to NinaAli0240

Who can say stop if it misses those aims? Not just you, hopefully

20points
NI
NinaAli0240
Replying to AnikaBrown0943

Our production lead and operator will decide with me. The first comparison needed two interventions, so we're not declaring it ready. One was a poor tray presentation; the other still needs explaining.

13points
LO
LouisAli0224
Replying to NinaAli0240

Will the next comparison repeat the complete order after any change, not only that troublesome pickup?

8points
EL
ElliotBell0683
Replying to NinaAli0240

Did the operator still prefer it with those interruptions included?

14points

Discussion closed

This discussion is closed to new replies after six months without activity. Last activity: .