Give both teams the same section with the actual strip and finger movement shown. Who owns resolving the clash?
Finger channels under the carton support strips
JoBarnes0592 · 15 Nov 2025, 02:57 UTC
13 replies
Our project engineer owns the layout. He has the two marked drawings but no combined revision yet. The count in the estimate still comes from the original pattern.
18 pointsI'd mark that count provisional now. My review had three drawings with different gaps before we put them together. It was surprisingly easy to think everybody had agreed the same arrangement.
23 pointsWhere is the packing operator in this review? A clever final gap can still be an awkward place to recover a damaged carton.
0 pointsAnika, useful question, but Jo hasn't said the recovery task yet. The layout needs that task defined rather than an assumed hand reaching into the gap.
15 pointsFair. Jo, who handles a damaged carton and where is that done? That's what I should have asked.
-1 pointsIs the carton in the section the packed construction you currently receive? Same outside size doesn't always mean the supports inside stayed put. We nearly carried an obsolete assumption through a changeover because the pallet picture was unchanged.
23 pointsHarish, yes, packaging checked our current packed sample. Anika, damaged cartons are removed upstream before pallet loading; the interruption procedure at the pallet still needs defining.
15 pointsKeep those as separate tasks in the review. Upstream rejection doesn't answer what happens if a carton is damaged during placement.
17 pointsUnderstood, Sofia. I've added that open question rather than describing the upstream check as recovery. The combined section now shows exactly where the channel crosses the strip.
23 pointsThanks for checking the construction. Has tooling offered a different withdrawal arrangement, or is packaging being asked to accept the same gap with a clearer drawing?
16 pointsTwo alternatives proposed: changed withdrawal space, or a lower-count layer. Neither approved by packaging yet. The estimate now labels the original count provisional.
4 pointsPlease post which survives the joint review. Including what happens to the interruption task, not only the carton count.
11 pointsDiscussion closed
This discussion is closed to new replies after six months without activity. Last activity: .