What changed visibly with the first tray: how it sat, how the housing was gripped, or just the number of successful transfers?
What did our FR5 locator trial actually improve?
SarahChen1198 · 28 Nov 2025, 01:17 UTC
16 replies
The tray stopped creeping sideways. The grip looked similar, but the short supervised run had no misses.
12 pointsDescribe those observations with the first tray identified, then state that the replacement missed. The locator may have solved one movement without establishing that all trays locate consistently.
7 pointsKeep both trays. Cheaper than arguing from memory.
3 pointsI've watched a locator blamed for a tray that never reached it properly. Not saying that's yours. I'd want to see the actual contact on the replacement before calling the idea bad.
16 pointsPavel, yes. Sarah, did anybody see the replacement seated at the locator before that miss?
20 pointsNot the lower contact. Our view is from above. Both trays are marked and retained now.
21 pointsThen the replacement's seating is still unknown. Make that explicit in the update, so the next shift doesn't read a suspected locator fault as an established one.
7 pointsCan the loader normally see that lower contact, Sarah? A check nobody can see is more of a wish.
1 pointsNo. The skirt hides it. I've asked the fixture designer how the loader is supposed to check seating.
18 pointsHas the designer actually compared both tray skirts yet?
13 pointsAnd keep the label locations in that comparison. Anything on the contact face belongs in the physical setup, not outside the trial because it looks like paperwork.
6 pointsBoth trays are with the designer. One has a thicker skirt at that corner. No label on the contact, Toby.
5 pointsWho controls which tray version is issued for this job? The eventual design decision needs to reach stores as well as the people doing the current comparison.
17 pointsStores owns issue. I've told them interchangeability is still open. My update now credits the first tray's reduced movement and names the replacement miss separately.
11 pointsGood distinction. No need to buy another locator until that comparison answers something.
20 pointsDiscussion closed
This discussion is closed to new replies after six months without activity. Last activity: .