The FR10 moves the bags but I keep rebuilding the presentation

MiaBaker0470 · 25 Jul 2026, 19:16 UTC

Reply to discussion
MI
MiaBaker0470
I've put a lot into our FR10 bag-to-carton setup, starting with 92 filled sample bags. The motion is working, but another bag shape means another round of presentation work, and the products keep changing. I'm attached to what I've built and struggling to decide how much ongoing attention this process deserves.

8 replies

TH
ThomasBrooks0799
Replying to MiaBaker0470

Separate the working transfer from the work required to feed it. Your effort is real. It does not tell you whether the next bag change is worth accepting.

22 points
LU
LucaChan1048
Replying to MiaBaker0470

Could somebody else handle the next change from your notes?

17 points
MI
MiaBaker0470
Replying to LucaChan1048

Not comfortably, Luca. The notes cover the current bag, but most of the presentation decisions are still mine. I don't want to call that operator reluctance when I haven't given them a repeatable changeover.

24 points
TH
ThomasBrooks0799
Replying to MiaBaker0470

Then the comparison needs a support allowance. Include your preparation time and someone else's learning time, but keep them separate. A one-off handover cost is different from adjustment every time the product changes.

8 points
LU
LucaChan1048
Replying to ThomasBrooks0799

Thomas, would restricting it to the established bag avoid scrapping useful work?

9 points
TH
ThomasBrooks0799
Replying to LucaChan1048

Possibly. It would need enough work of that shape to justify keeping the setup available. Restricting its scope is a sensible option to cost, not evidence that keeping it will pay.

6 points
MI
MiaBaker0470
Replying to ThomasBrooks0799

I've stopped adding new bag shapes for now, and we're recording the preparation alongside the transfer. That feels less like a verdict on all the effort, which helps. The established shape stays under review while we work out who could actually support it.

3 points
LU
LucaChan1048
Replying to MiaBaker0470

Thanks for coming back. Interested whether that narrower job survives the support review.

24 points

Add to the discussion

Welcome to Application Robot

Everyone can read the forum. Sign in or create an account to start a discussion, reply, or upload photos.

Forgot your password?

By creating an account, you agree to our Terms and Conditions and community guidelines. Read our Privacy Policy for how your information is handled.