One demo got the nice tray

RobinAbbott0077 · 8 Dec 2024, 19:32 UTC

Closed
RO
RobinAbbott0077
I'm comparing unloading demos. Our battered tray went to one bidder; the UR5e demo used machined pockets. Fair comparison?

12 replies

LU
LucaBarnes0526
Replying to RobinAbbott0077

No, because you don't yet know whether you're seeing a robot difference or a tray difference, and that doesn't mean either bidder did bad work.

7 points
RO
RobinAbbott0077
Replying to LucaBarnes0526

Would sending both our worst tray actually tell us anything useful?

6 points
LU
LucaBarnes0526
Replying to RobinAbbott0077

Yes, if it's representative of trays you intend to keep using; an exceptionally damaged one might answer the wrong question.

17 points
DA
DanLoop
Replying to RobinAbbott0077

Was either demonstration required to handle pocket position variation, or did you leave the tray design to the bidder?

15 points
RO
RobinAbbott0077
Replying to DanLoop

We said existing trays preferred. That's doing a lot of work, isn't it.

2 points
DA
DanLoop
Replying to RobinAbbott0077

It is ambiguous; request separate prices for retaining your trays and replacing them, with the demonstrated configuration identified in each offer.

2 points
LU
LucaBarnes0526
Replying to RobinAbbott0077

I'd send a normal tray too, because our worst one lived under a bench for years and wasn't evidence of everyday production.

11 points
AI
AishaBarnes0605
Replying to RobinAbbott0077

What did you actually observe on the old tray? Slow placement and failed placement are different results. Did the video show either?

-4 points
LU
LucaBarnes0526
Replying to AishaBarnes0605

And did somebody straighten it between takes? I've been caught counting edited successes before.

22 points
AN
AnikaBrown0943
Replying to LucaBarnes0526

Nobody here has seen a failure yet. We're getting ahead of the video.

19 points
LU
LucaBarnes0526
Replying to AnikaBrown0943

You're right, I made my bad experience sound like something that happened in this demo; I only meant to ask about continuity.

6 points
RO
RobinAbbott0077
Replying to AishaBarnes0605

It showed slower approaches, no failures. I've asked both for the same tray trial and two prices.

19 points

Discussion closed

This discussion is closed to new replies after six months without activity. Last activity: .