FR10 loading review without the open tool or machine door
ReeceChan1080 · 15 Jun 2026, 16:31 UTC
20 replies
The integrator should own the combined arrangement, with the machine and tool suppliers providing identified geometry; an arm choice stays provisional until the complete proposed route has been assessed.
16pointsPut machine service space in the layout too. We've had a robot position clear the normal movement and still occupy the place needed to remove a panel. Different problem, same floor space
6pointsDo you have a definite tool assembly to assess, Reece, or only a gripper model? A dimensioned assembly outline is a useful inexpensive starting point, but it must describe the proposed fingers and adapter as well.
20pointsOnly a gripper model and a finger concept so far. I can request the assembly, but I can't honestly give the reviewer its working envelope yet
18pointsThat is exactly where our earlier FR5 review stalled: brochure present, adapter and fingers absent. I kept the candidate provisional. It was missing evidence about the arrangement, not evidence that the arm could never do the job.
17pointsIsabel, did purchasing accept that distinction? People hear provisional as 'please get three prices for something larger', then the new arm inherits the same missing tool drawing
0pointsI cannot claim the whole purchasing process was settled. In the discussion I posted, I had decided to keep the comparison provisional; the complete assembly was still what we lacked.
25pointsBruno's service space needs an owner too. Maintenance should mark what must be accessed or removed. Don't expect a tool designer to guess your panel-removal job.
13pointsIn our teaching bay I also want the routine fixture change shown. Not only repair access. The equipment can be technically reachable while the person changing a fixture has nowhere sensible to put the removed one.
2pointsBeatrice, is that storage during the change or the route out of the bay? I would show both if they differ, because the person writing the instruction may otherwise assume one convenient empty space serves every step.
2pointsBoth in my example. We initially drew a place for the removed fixture but forgot how it got there. Thank you for separating the two; that is clearer than my note saying changeover space.
22pointsThe integrator has agreed to own the combined review. Machine service and fixture-change areas are being marked by our team while the tool assembly is completed; no alternative base position has been proposed
5pointsKeep that last point visible, Reece. Otherwise someone may read all our access comments as approval for a base move that nobody has actually drawn.
10pointsAnd keep geometric access separate from application safety approval. A route that fits is necessary evidence, not a complete decision about the supervised cell.
6pointsWe once compared clearances from two drawings with different reference origins. I'd ask for the combined model's datum and revisions to be explicit before discussing small margins.
16pointsIvan, did the difference change the arrangement or only the reported margin? That seems worth distinguishing before a review spends money on a new model.
13pointsReported margin in our case. The physical arrangement was unchanged; the drawings needed reconciliation. I can't infer the effect here.
8pointsI like starting with that reconciliation. Paying for detail on a layout nobody agrees about is frustrating, especially when maintenance is already booking time to review it
7pointsWe now have an identified assembly and combined layout, but the empty-tool withdrawal passes through a door fitting. The integrator is reviewing that interference; neither a base move nor a different arm is selected
19pointsThat is a specific interference to resolve, not a general reach verdict; any proposed tool or layout change must return through the combined review, including the access areas your team added.
16pointsAdd to the discussion
Welcome to Application Robot
Everyone can read the forum. Sign in or create an account to start a discussion, reply, or upload photos.
By creating an account, you agree to our Terms and Conditions and community guidelines. Read our Privacy Policy for how your information is handled.