My FR10 saving still needs my colleague at the fixture

AnilArcher0375 · 28 Jan 2026, 08:16 UTC

Closed
AN
AnilArcher0375
I priced an FR10 to unload connector housings. My colleague asked who releases the fixture, checks the housing and changes the receiving tray. Apparently my labour saving has three unpaid helpers. What should a small pilot settle first?

14 replies

HA
HarishBrooks0837
Replying to AnilArcher0375

Follow one ordinary order through the current job before borrowing a robot. Include those three tasks and the interruptions. You're trying to find a chunk of work that can actually move away from your colleague, not make the arm look busy.

19 points
AN
AnilArcher0375
Replying to HarishBrooks0837

We already have a shift sheet, but it only counts finished housings. Doesn't show who clears the fixture. I'll ask for an observation with that included.

15 points
LU
LuisBrooks0869
Replying to AnilArcher0375

I once timed unloading as the seconds between picking up a part and putting it down. The operator politely let me finish, then showed me the fixture cleaning, the awkward part she put aside and the tray she had to fetch from another room. My little timing wasn't false; it just wasn't the job. Keep a whole order visible, including the last few housings. If a proposed pilot needs somebody standing there doing the omitted work, give that person a name in the staffing plan and count their time. They do not become free because the robot is in the photograph.

14 points
AN
AnilArcher0375
Replying to LuisBrooks0869

Colleague agreed to the observation, provided it doesn't become an unofficial extra shift. Fair condition. Supervisor has to arrange cover before we do it.

13 points
HE
HenryBaker0438
Replying to AnilArcher0375

Can the fixture release itself in the proposed job, or have you only priced the gripper?

6 points
HA
HarishBrooks0837
Replying to LuisBrooks0869

Luis, yes to the full order, but I'd still break out the tasks inside it; Anil needs to know whether one expensive exception is hiding an otherwise useful option.

20 points
LU
LuisBrooks0869
Replying to HarishBrooks0837

Agreed, I mean observe the whole order, not squash it into one average.

7 points
DA
DanielBrown0913
Replying to AnilArcher0375

Include where suspect housings go. A tidy output tray can conceal a little reject pile that someone else spends the afternoon sorting. Quality needs to own that decision in the pilot.

6 points
AN
AnilArcher0375
Replying to DanielBrown0913

Henry, only the gripper. Fixture release wasn't in my quote. Daniel, quality currently takes the suspect ones at the bench, so that handoff belongs in the observation too.

9 points
HE
HenryBaker0438
Replying to AnilArcher0375

Then ask for the complete fixture option before anyone treats your price as a purchase budget.

10 points
AN
AnilArcher0375
Replying to AnilArcher0375

Supervisor arranged cover and we observed an order. Unloading was brief; release and cleaning kept bringing my colleague back. I've withdrawn the staffing saving and asked for a fixture-inclusive concept, not a robot trial date.

13 points
DA
DanielBrown0913
Replying to AnilArcher0375

Did the suspect-part handoff take much of that person's time, or was fixture work the main interruption?

11 points
AN
AnilArcher0375
Replying to DanielBrown0913

Fixture work was the repeated interruption. Two suspect housings went to quality together. Thanks Luis, the whole-order view caught the cleaning that my original timing never saw.

11 points
HA
HarishBrooks0837
Replying to AnilArcher0375

That's enough to stop using the old saving. Whether a redesigned fixture earns its cost is another question, and your colleague shouldn't have to fund the answer with spare time.

4 points

Discussion closed

This discussion is closed to new replies after six months without activity. Last activity: .